2023 drafted QB's.

[feltdizz]

Yup, Howell was abysmal today for sure in his 4th start, but I don't get the constant trolling on these forums.

trolling of Steeler players?

or do you think joking people who celebrate bad games by Steelers is trolling?

[Steel Maniac]

Where did I say that he did not play well vs. the Bengals last week? Please do not ruin this thread. Let's stick to the topic of the thread. You can comment on the four 2nd year QB's . I would like to see your rankings of the play this season.

Joel, he wants you to capture his post so I can see them. Don't fall for his lame tricks. Please don't capture his post. Respond if you must but don't play into his weird little games.


**** Back to the thread topic: Joel, what do you think of Stroud so far? He's accounting for himself rather well I think.

[hawaiiansteel]

Joel, he wants you to capture his post so I can see them. Don't fall for his lame tricks. Please don't capture his post. Respond if you must but don't play into his weird little games.

Seriously, nobody cares.

[Steel Maniac]

Joel, what do you think of Stroud so far? He's accounting for himself rather well I think.

[Joel Buchsbaum]

Joel, he wants you to capture his post so I can see them. Don't fall for his lame tricks. Please don't capture his post. Respond if you must but don't play into his weird little games.


**** Back to the thread topic: Joel, what do you think of Stroud so far? He's accounting for himself rather well I think.

He's not bad. Far better than Young.


For the weekly update.

1. Purdy
2. Pickett
3. Ridder
4. Howell

Season to date

1. Purdy
2. Howell
3A. Pickett
3.B Riddler


Weekly update.

[Joel Buchsbaum]

1 ) Howell Not a big passing day for Howell who only passed the ball 23 times. But he threw 3 td's

2 ) Ridder. He threw for 307 yards, but it took him 48 pass to get there and threw 3 interceptions. 2 td's.

3) Purdy. A bad day for him, which is a first. He struggled. Just 125 yard passing, 1 td 1 int. Many of the key offensive guys on the 49ers were injured. The 49 comitted 12 penalties. Limited passing attempts.




Overall

1. Purdy
2. Howell
3. Ridder
4. Pickett

[WindyCitySteel]

Purdy is a product of the system and supporting cast, his PFF grade is actually lower than last year's - 73.0.

It's like playing QB at OSU, tons of talent and great system. If he messes up, no bigs, the team will pick him up. Zero pressure playing there.

He's lifting feathers on the moon, Pickett is playing in underwater in leg weights.

[crushedspirit]

Film review shows more than just a QB in a good system. Brock is smarter and more accurate, especially when throwing with anticipation. Pickett's 53.8 rating might be a tad generous.

[WindyCitySteel]

Film review shows more than just a QB in a good system. Brock is smarter and more accurate, especially when throwing with anticipation. Pickett's 53.8 rating might be a tad generous.

He's playing better than Pickett, which the grades reflect, but he's not Mahomes or Allen or even Tua. He's a guy won won the lottery.

[NorthCoast]

Film review shows more than just a QB in a good system. Brock is smarter and more accurate, especially when throwing with anticipation. Pickett's 53.8 rating might be a tad generous.

Ya know, I can't remember the last time I saw Pickett throw an anticipation pass (the kind that is thrown before the receiver ever makes his break.)

[crushedspirit]

KP8 waits for WRs to run open more often than not which is a huge red flag. Meanwhile,

PFF can't show you that. Brady was a master of it over the middle.

[hawaiiansteel]

Overall

1. Purdy
2. Howell
3. Ridder
4. Pickett

where do you rank Malik Willis and Matt Corral?

[WindyCitySteel]

PFF can't show you that. Brady was a master of it over the middle.

PFF accounts for all of that, and Purdy is no Brady. Wait until his contract is up for renewal, the Niners will not pay him and lose his supporting cast.

[Joel Buchsbaum]

where do you rank Malik Willis and Matt Corral?

I am only ranking guys that play. Corral was a 15 wonderlic score guy that has depression issues. ( I don't do interviews, nor was I aware of his score on draft day ) and Wills played weak competition in college and was #1 among Tomlin liked QB's. That is where I rank em'

Why do you ask? It Pickett's play and health that concern me.

[crushedspirit]

PFF accounts for all of that, and Purdy is no Brady. Wait until his contract is up for renewal, the Niners will not pay him and lose his supporting cast.

I don't compare him to a Brady or Mahomes. Purdy has the look of a good starting QB learning the ropes with questions to be answered come playoff time.