I love the signing because EVEN IF IT FAILS

[Captain Lemming]

He's not clearly better than any other QB in this division; we still might have 3 teams ahead of us in that dept (2 anyway). Hope I'm wrong, but I don't see this move significantly helping our record this season, and it sure doesn't seem to be anything that will improve us long-term.

Saying it again. Last season, old man Russ had more touchdown passes than OUR TEAM HAS HAD since Ben retired.

That is DESPITE being SAT for TWO GAMES.

That is a SIGNIFICANT upgrade to a 10 win playoff team. And he did not have NEAR the weapons he has now to play with.

[Northern_Blitz]

I know some have the immediate instinct to look for the negative in everything, but there is no downside to this signing.

I mentioned in another thread that I think the front office rightly sees that we have a three (3) year window before Watt, Minkah and others start to fade. They aren't willing to wait until Pickett "gets it". Just looking at last season, Wilson is 10x better than Pickett. I love that the organization is saying win now. Just remember Art's comments after the season.

INn reality, this is more than a one year solution unless Wilson falls apart. This is a "prove it" but likely he has at least three good years in him.

This is where I'm at.

I do have some concerns about being a good teammate and stuff. But we can cut him for basically no downside if we want. And that if that happens, it might almost end his career. So he has to be motivated to come in and kick ass.

[Northern_Blitz]

you all can say what you want but at the end of the day if Russell Wilson can replicate what he did last year statistically here in Pittsburgh 66.4% completion percentage 26 TDs and 8 ints ( double the amount of TD passes we had last year and less INTs ) that spells 3-4 more wins IMO and that changes the entire playoff picture ... football is about matchups so instead of playing the 1 or 2 seed you potentially are the 1 or 2 seed playing the 7 or 8th seed and at home ..... that likely roadmaps you into the conference championship game instead of 1 and done ....

we do not need superstar play at QB with the way our defense plays we just have to have a legit NFL QB who can make some plays ...Wilson can do that .....

for those saying its wasting KP , that is laughable what it is a waste is playing Pickett and letting the prime years of TJ and Minkah go by the way side and the final years of Cam go down the drain ... thats beyond wasteful that tragic

If we can just be an average offense, this team will be good (as long as we don't lose most of the ILBs and Ss again).

[Northern_Blitz]

That's your intepretation. Albert Breer had this to say:

"The Steelers' one-year deal with signing Russell Wilson is, as expected, at the $1.21 million league minimum, per sources. Pittsburgh was very clear setting expectations with Wilson on his visit. He knows what it is. He'll come in and compete."

Now having said this, I would be mildly shocked if Pickett outplays Wilson for the start. It would tell me that Wilson has fallen off a lot more than people realize.

I think this is more relationship management with KP.

Just like he was still QB1 when Mason had "the hot hand".

We'll see though.

[SS Laser]

That's your intepretation. Albert Breer had this to say:

"The Steelers' one-year deal with signing Russell Wilson is, as expected, at the $1.21 million league minimum, per sources. Pittsburgh was very clear setting expectations with Wilson on his visit. He knows what it is. He'll come in and compete."

Now having said this, I would be mildly shocked if Pickett outplays Wilson for the start. It would tell me that Wilson has fallen off a lot more than people realize.

Both QB’s have to learn the new system. I would bet Russ picks it up faster. Has age/ being a vet is in his favor.
So he should look good or better then KP in the new system.

[Northern_Blitz]

You think we'll have Wilson on board for 3 years? Interesting.
If he has a good season, I don't see the Steelers paying what he will demand for his next contract. If he has a bad season, I don't see the Steelers keeping him on. I think this is a one-year rental.

We shall see.

I wonder.

We've been good at not pushing Watt's cap hit down the road. And there might be some things we can do to reduce Cam's hit for next season.

If Wilson balls out, I don't think you let above average QBs go if you think you can win. And maybe he doesn't go full market value if he has success here at a low number?

[Oviedo]

Saying it again. Last season, old man Russ had more touchdown passes than OUR TEAM HAS HAD since Ben retired.

That is DESPITE being SAT for TWO GAMES.

That is a SIGNIFICANT upgrade to a 10 win playoff team. And he did not have NEAR the weapons he has now to play with.

I feel the same

[Captain Lemming]

This better work. If not, while cheap.. its sets us back a year.

In the unlikely case that Russ struggles bench him at midsession. Kenny will have enough time to show whether he is worth keeping with a new OC.

If Russ is significantly better as I suspect, extend him. He WILL NOT be near as valuable on the open market as he cannot carry a bad team. Last season Russ is a huge improvement for us but not a savior for a bad team anymore.

Cam gets ONE SEASON to get his ring. If we fail, but Russ gets us deep into the playoffs? Having just got paid, Russ goal is to cement his legacy with another ring.

Cutting Cam gets Russ paid easy.

I could see us have SEVERAL YEARS to get a ring with Russ that way.

[Eich]

I don't think Kenny can win the job to be QB1 to start the season. This will be another faux competition in camp.

It's Russ' job to lose. And he would have to outright stink in preseason to lose it. Or get injured.

Wilson is QB1 on day 1. From there, it's anyone's guess on how short a leash he might operate on.

[Captain Lemming]

I wonder.

We've been good at not pushing Watt's cap hit down the road. And there might be some things we can do to reduce Cam's hit for next season.

If Wilson balls out, I don't think you let above average QBs go if you think you can win. And maybe he doesn't go full market value if he has success here at a low number?

My point EXACTLY.
Russ was in the room with Khan and Tomlin for HOURS for a reason people.

Would not surprise AT ALL if Russ told them if he succeeds he WANTS to get another ring more than maximizing his money.

I said it before. Russ joins us ONLY if he sees us as his best opportunity to WIN.

I think he (like some of us) have visions of his early success as a solid game manager of a hard running defensive team.

[Chucktownsteeler]

Russ wants a chance for another ring and:

S-T-A-B-I-L-I-T-Y.

Won't get that many other places.

He wants to play 5 mores years and hoist 2 more Lombardis. Time will tell.

[Iron City Inc.]

With the new Wilson / Pickett combo does that mean we play "Mustang Sally " at the 2 minute warning?

[Captain Lemming]

With the new Wilson / Pickett combo does that mean we play "Mustang Sally " at the s minute warning?

Dang… that no doubt went over nearly everybody here my fellow BOOMER.

Pretty funny if you know the reference.

When the youngins have to Google Wilson Pickett to get your humor it is gonna fall flat for most.

[Captain Lemming]

Dang… that no doubt went over nearly everybody here my fellow BOOMER.

Pretty funny if you know the reference.

When the youngins have to Google Wilson Pickett to get your humor it is gonna fall flat for most.

Hmmm, kinda sounds like something the OC would call in a game?

I would suggest Mustang Sally be the name of a rare formation featuring both QBs

[Shawn]

I love the signing. High reward low risk in my book.

BUT IF IT GOES SOUTH We get the best fail nickname in STEELER HISTORY. Better than Dwight hands of stone. Better than BURNT Alexander. Better than my classic BustWheat.

My friends I introduce to you the best fail nickname in franchise history.

Russ too old in the STEEL city?

RUST WILSON
(tm Captain Lemming)

Heck this is the Mean Joe, Fast Willie, Steel Curtain of fail nicknames.

I like it for several reasons. If he balls out the Steelers will make a run. If he doesn?t didn?t cost us much and proves that they have zero confidence in KP which means they are not as stupid as most thought. Win win.