Honest eval after today

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Terrapin
    Pro Bowler
    • Sep 2017
    • 2081

    Honest eval after today

    This is not a very good team. I won't even get into how subpar the coaching consistently is. That's a given at this point. From not having the team ready against scrub teams, to the game plan, no adjustments, insane play calls, etc. It is what it is, and that's never going to change.

    QBs. Rudolph is trash. Plain and simple. If Ben misses another game we need to go with Haskins. He sucks too, but has a higher upside, plus can scramble a bit. Regardless, we need MAJOR upgrades at this position next year, cause none of these 3 guys are any good.

    RB: Najee is a stud. Should be the clear centerpiece of this offense for a few years.

    WRs: When Ray Ray Mcloud is leading your WR corps, you're in trouble. But really, what's the difference? JuJu sucks. Claypool is a few blunts away from being Martavis Bryant. Johnson is a #2, not a 1. Not good.

    Line: Sorry, there's nobody good whatsoever. Green is pathetic

    Defense: Cam. TJ. Haden. That's it. Nobody else is worth a damn, and aside from Minkah, nobody else would probably be a starter for even an average team. It's rare when you can 'notice' how bad an ILB is. But Bush stands out in that regard every game. Missing tackles, blowing assignments, getting burned, etc. Talk about a wasted pick. Speaking of wastes, can someone contact Missing Persons to see if they can locate Tuitt?

    You hear a lot in other sports, 'keep these guys and move everyone else'. Well if that's the case for the Steelers, the list of 'holds' would be Najee, Diontae, Muth, Cam, TJ, Haden, Boswell, and the punter. Everyone else can go.
  • LPMAN
    Pro Bowler
    • Sep 2021
    • 2032

    #2
    You had me UNTIL : Defense: Cam. TJ. Haden. That's it. Nobody else is worth a damn

    Comment

    • NJ-STEELER
      Legend
      • May 2008
      • 12563

      #3
      my honest assessment of mason is what I've said for a few years

      his ball does not seem to have enough zip on it to be a quality NFL starter. once in a while you might see a ball with some zip but its few and far between. that's what my eyes tell me

      Comment

      • NJ-STEELER
        Legend
        • May 2008
        • 12563

        #4
        i was wanting a trade for rodgers in the off season but I doubt he's enough to overcome the team's weaknesses to challenge for a title

        we need a rebuild/reload

        Comment

        • Steel Maniac
          Banned
          • Apr 2017
          • 19472

          #5
          Originally posted by Terrapin
          This is not a very good team. I won't even get into how subpar the coaching consistently is. That's a given at this point. From not having the team ready against scrub teams, to the game plan, no adjustments, insane play calls, etc. It is what it is, and that's never going to change.

          QBs. Rudolph is trash. Plain and simple. If Ben misses another game we need to go with Haskins. He sucks too, but has a higher upside, plus can scramble a bit. Regardless, we need MAJOR upgrades at this position next year, cause none of these 3 guys are any good.

          RB: Najee is a stud. Should be the clear centerpiece of this offense for a few years.

          WRs: When Ray Ray Mcloud is leading your WR corps, you're in trouble. But really, what's the difference? JuJu sucks. Claypool is a few blunts away from being Martavis Bryant. Johnson is a #2, not a 1. Not good.

          Line: Sorry, there's nobody good whatsoever. Green is pathetic

          Defense: Cam. TJ. Haden. That's it. Nobody else is worth a damn, and aside from Minkah, nobody else would probably be a starter for even an average team. It's rare when you can 'notice' how bad an ILB is. But Bush stands out in that regard every game. Missing tackles, blowing assignments, getting burned, etc. Talk about a wasted pick. Speaking of wastes, can someone contact Missing Persons to see if they can locate Tuitt?

          You hear a lot in other sports, 'keep these guys and move everyone else'. Well if that's the case for the Steelers, the list of 'holds' would be Najee, Diontae, Muth, Cam, TJ, Haden, Boswell, and the punter. Everyone else can go.
          Post of the year with no ball washing whatsoever.

          We get a string of bad teams and guys start saying the O-line is good.

          O-line is garbage ; we passed on Humphrey at center and it will haunt us all year.

          Poor Najee; working so hard… I’m scared for him because he struggles mightily after contact that I’m afraid he’ll hurt himself.

          Comment

          • Terrapin
            Pro Bowler
            • Sep 2017
            • 2081

            #6
            Originally posted by LPMAN
            You had me UNTIL : Defense: Cam. TJ. Haden. That's it. Nobody else is worth a damn
            Who else do you think is good? Minkah and Bush can't tackle. Edmunds?

            Comment

            • hawaiiansteel
              Legend
              • May 2008
              • 35649

              #7
              Originally posted by Steel Maniac
              Post of the year with no ball washing whatsoever.
              you sure are obsessed with testicles.

              wonder why?

              Comment

              • Steel Maniac
                Banned
                • Apr 2017
                • 19472

                #8
                Originally posted by NJ-STEELER
                i was wanting a trade for rodgers in the off season but I doubt he's enough to overcome the team's weaknesses to challenge for a title

                we need a rebuild/reload
                What areas would you commit our first 3 draft picks? Just curious.

                Comment

                • hawaiiansteel
                  Legend
                  • May 2008
                  • 35649

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Terrapin
                  Who else do you think is good? Minkah and Bush can't tackle. Edmunds?
                  it will be interesting to see if we give Minkah a big contract extension.

                  Comment

                  • Steel Maniac
                    Banned
                    • Apr 2017
                    • 19472

                    #10
                    Originally posted by NJ-STEELER
                    i was wanting a trade for rodgers in the off season but I doubt he's enough to overcome the team's weaknesses to challenge for a title

                    we need a rebuild/reload
                    Tell me how’d you use our first 3 draft picks?

                    Comment

                    • hawaiiansteel
                      Legend
                      • May 2008
                      • 35649

                      #11
                      Originally posted by NJ-STEELER
                      i was wanting a trade for rodgers in the off season but I doubt he's enough to overcome the team's weaknesses to challenge for a title

                      we need a rebuild/reload
                      short-term fix.

                      we need a longer-term answer.

                      Comment

                      • Terrapin
                        Pro Bowler
                        • Sep 2017
                        • 2081

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Steel Maniac
                        Tell me how’d you use our first 3 draft picks?
                        Assuming we don't bring in Rodgers?
                        Kenny Pickett
                        Oline
                        BPA. Preferably Oline or WR

                        If we bring in Rodgers;
                        Oline
                        Oline
                        BPA, preferably WR or ILB

                        Comment

                        • Captain Lemming
                          Legend
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 16041

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Terrapin
                          This is not a very good team. I won't even get into how subpar the coaching consistently is. That's a given at this point. From not having the team ready against scrub teams, to the game plan, no adjustments, insane play calls, etc. It is what it is, and that's never going to change.

                          QBs. Rudolph is trash. Plain and simple. If Ben misses another game we need to go with Haskins. He sucks too, but has a higher upside, plus can scramble a bit. Regardless, we need MAJOR upgrades at this position next year, cause none of these 3 guys are any good.

                          RB: Najee is a stud. Should be the clear centerpiece of this offense for a few years.

                          WRs: When Ray Ray Mcloud is leading your WR corps, you're in trouble. But really, what's the difference? JuJu sucks. Claypool is a few blunts away from being Martavis Bryant. Johnson is a #2, not a 1. Not good.

                          Line: Sorry, there's nobody good whatsoever. Green is pathetic

                          Defense: Cam. TJ. Haden. That's it. Nobody else is worth a damn, and aside from Minkah, nobody else would probably be a starter for even an average team. It's rare when you can 'notice' how bad an ILB is. But Bush stands out in that regard every game. Missing tackles, blowing assignments, getting burned, etc. Talk about a wasted pick. Speaking of wastes, can someone contact Missing Persons to see if they can locate Tuitt?

                          You hear a lot in other sports, 'keep these guys and move everyone else'. Well if that's the case for the Steelers, the list of 'holds' would be Najee, Diontae, Muth, Cam, TJ, Haden, Boswell, and the punter. Everyone else can go.
                          Don't disagree with your.player assessment overall

                          That being said, bad coaching on to of a bad roster would seem to result in more than 3 losses at this point in the season.
                          sigpic



                          In view of the fact that Mike Tomlin has matched Cowhers record I give him the designation:

                          TCFCLTC-
                          The Coach Formerly Considered Less Than Cowher

                          Comment

                          • JTP53609
                            Pro Bowler
                            • Sep 2009
                            • 1888

                            #14
                            I think trubisky would be a decent pick up, young, decent upside and showed some flashes in Chicago where offenses are consistently vanilla and weak

                            Comment

                            • Northern_Blitz
                              Legend
                              • Dec 2008
                              • 24373

                              #15
                              Originally posted by hawaiiansteel
                              it will be interesting to see if we give Minkah a big contract extension.
                              He'll still get a big contract.

                              2 all pros in his rookie contract.

                              Comment

                              Working...