I don't think so. I think they all totally reflect the Steelers philosophy when it comes to drafting in the first round: the guy be a productive leader of his college football team (I think Bud was voted a team captain, Jarvis SEC DPOY). We don't take flyers on guys.
Staying on Jarvis for a sec: While I do agree with the general sentiment around him (needle doesn't seem to be ticking up) and the apparent fact that he really doesn't beat guys 1-on-1, I don't really think that means he can't be productive and approach fan expectations of him. To be perfectly honest, my favorite Steeler (Greg Lloyd) didn't necessarily whip Tackles because of his speed or strength. And Jarvis' coach (Peezy), while he feasted on poor Tackles, he really didn't do much against the Jon Ogdens of the world (who did?, but you get my point).
Both Porter and Lloyd were more blitzers than they were pass-rushers. The scheme (elements of surprise) really dictated how often they got to the QB. Both those guys actually needed that element; neither really was good enough to consistently do it on their own talent. I think Jarvis has that ability... or at least I hope he does.
Staying on Jarvis for a sec: While I do agree with the general sentiment around him (needle doesn't seem to be ticking up) and the apparent fact that he really doesn't beat guys 1-on-1, I don't really think that means he can't be productive and approach fan expectations of him. To be perfectly honest, my favorite Steeler (Greg Lloyd) didn't necessarily whip Tackles because of his speed or strength. And Jarvis' coach (Peezy), while he feasted on poor Tackles, he really didn't do much against the Jon Ogdens of the world (who did?, but you get my point).
Both Porter and Lloyd were more blitzers than they were pass-rushers. The scheme (elements of surprise) really dictated how often they got to the QB. Both those guys actually needed that element; neither really was good enough to consistently do it on their own talent. I think Jarvis has that ability... or at least I hope he does.

Comment