Redman vs Mendy

[Shawn]

Re: Redman vs Mendy

I agree Redman should get more carries. I can't agree that he is a better back. Mendenhall has it all...except an adequate line. I can't take ypc as a serious measuring stick until I see it over many many carries done in similar rushing situations.

[CanadianSteel]

Re: Redman vs Mendy

Moore 2010 Carries 33 Yards 99 YPC 3.0
2009 Carries 35 Yards 118 YPC 3.4

Redman 2010 Carries 52 Yards 242 YPC 4.8

I think the real question should be Moore vs Redman. Again love what Moore has done for us as a 3rd down back, but i just think he is a wasted roster spot. Mendy has great hands, keep him in on 3rd down and give Red some of Mendys carries to offset the workload.

[feltdizz]

Re: Redman vs Mendy

Moore 2010 Carries 33 Yards 99 YPC 3.0
2009 Carries 35 Yards 118 YPC 3.4

Redman 2010 Carries 52 Yards 242 YPC 4.8

I think the real question should be Moore vs Redman. Again love what Moore has done for us as a 3rd down back, but i just think he is a wasted roster spot. Mendy has great hands, keep him in on 3rd down and give Red some of Mendys carries to offset the workload.

since Redman got 52 touches to Moore's 33 and 35 the last 2 years I think it's safe to say Redman>Moore

I still want Redman to get 100+ next year... and at least 30 more this year

[ikestops85]

Re: Redman vs Mendy

I've got an idea. Let's take away Mendy's 2 longest runs in each game and then see what his ypc is. It's probably somewhere around FWP's.

[RuthlessBurgher]

Re: Redman vs Mendy

I've got an idea. Let's take away Mendy's 2 longest runs in each game and then see what his ypc is. It's probably somewhere around FWP's.

Just imagine if we took away Wallace's 2 longest catches each game. He would REALLY suck!