Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

[SidSmythe]

Does anyone see two similar players???

-both drop big time passes, but Edwards keeps getting on the field & Sweed doesn't.

If you ask me, when Sweed has been out there he's gotten open, just couldn't finish the plays .... Edwards too can get open but fails to make the catch.

Are the Steelers too impatient or just want perfection??? or am I missing something here???

[pittpete]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Is it impatience or perhaps an attitude problem for Sweed?
Honestly we as fans aren't at practices and meeting so it could be anything.
IMHO we really havnt given him a chance.

[MeetJoeGreene]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Does anyone see two similar players???

-both drop big time passes, but Edwards keeps getting on the field & Sweed doesn't.

If you ask me, when Sweed has been out there he's gotten open, just couldn't finish the plays .... Edwards too can get open but fails to make the catch.

Are the Steelers too impatient or just want perfection??? or am I missing something here???

Yes.
1.) We had a potential blooming star in Wallace that we couldn't keep off the field. And it worked That limited the reps Sweed received.

2.) Sweed (probably) just gave up and cashed it in - not putting forth effort in practice leading to his IR.

[SteelAbility]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Well, the sample set on Sweed is pretty small right now, so you can't really tell what his long-term drop % is. Unfortunately for him, he picked two really big plays to demonstrate his drop skills.

That being said, I'd be up for a straight-up Sweed-for-Edwards trade. :P

[SteelAbility]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Is it impatience or perhaps an attitude problem for Sweed?
Honestly we as fans aren't at practices and meeting so it could be anything.
IMHO we really havnt given him a chance.

If you were to ask Sweed if his problem is ignorance or apathy, you'd probably get an "I don't know and I don't care" response.

[steelblood]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Too impatient? He is still on the team even though he dropped two sure TDs in playoff games and cost us that game in Cincy this season. He has dropped almost every big pass thrown to him. Lord knows what his mystery illness was/is. Dude is still here and will be in camp. The Browns played Edwards because 1. he was a top ten pick, 2. the are talent poor at WR, 3. Edwards actually produced and in many games was effective. Maybe if Sweed would have caught ONE of those TDs, he'd bet more opportunities.

[feltdizz]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Change the title to Grisham vs. Sweed and we can talk

I wouldn't be surprised if depression was Sweed's illness. I won't touch it because I think those 2 drops changed his career path. He can still bounce back but a ton of players spiral down real hard. It could be serious. Wallace emerging can't help his confidence either.

[steelsnis]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Sweed (probably) just gave up and cashed it in - not putting forth effort in practice leading to his IR.

That's not necessarily the case. From reports I've read (Lolley, Bouchette, Bires, etc), Sweed is a very hard worker in practice and by all accounts a really good kid.

I'm leaning with you feltdizz on the depression angle. My guess is when he dropped that TD against Cincy and got put on the bench, he couldn't figure out the right way to deal. He's got one more shot next season. Let's hope he makes the most of it.

[feltdizz]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Sweed (probably) just gave up and cashed it in - not putting forth effort in practice leading to his IR.

That's not necessarily the case. From reports I've read (Lolley, Bouchette, Bires, etc), Sweed is a very hard worker in practice and by all accounts a really good kid.

I'm leaning with you feltdizz on the depression angle. My guess is when he dropped that TD against Cincy and got put on the bench, he couldn't figure out the right way to deal. He's got one more shot next season. Let's hope he makes the most of it.

He will need a Holmes/Wallace game winning TD catch in every playoff game to ever get over the drops. 2 playoff drops and a huge Cincy drop.. hard to overcome.

[papillon]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Sweed (probably) just gave up and cashed it in - not putting forth effort in practice leading to his IR.

That's not necessarily the case. From reports I've read (Lolley, Bouchette, Bires, etc), Sweed is a very hard worker in practice and by all accounts a really good kid.

I'm leaning with you feltdizz on the depression angle. My guess is when he dropped that TD against Cincy and got put on the bench, he couldn't figure out the right way to deal. He's got one more shot next season. Let's hope he makes the most of it.

He will need a Holmes/Wallace game winning TD catch in every playoff game to ever get over the drops. 2 playoff drops and a huge Cincy drop.. hard to overcome.

All he needs is to be successful on some level to get his confidence back. The only reason I continue to want to give him a chance is because he gets open so easy. He's made catches in traffic during pre-season, so I'm certain he can catch. All he needs is to have some success and he'll do fine. I'm hoping he turns it around next year.

By all accounts he works hard in practice and is a good kid; I want him to succeed. I'd hate for two drops to destroy his career with the Steelers.

Pappy

[Oviedo]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Change the title to Grisham vs. Sweed and we can talk

I wouldn't be surprised if depression was Sweed's illness. I won't touch it because I think those 2 drops changed his career path. He can still bounce back but a ton of players spiral down real hard. It could be serious. Wallace emerging can't help his confidence either.

I have to agree that Sweed was probably having issues with depression which is why it wasn't discussed. If you recall since his rookie year it was widely written that Sweed put lots of pressure on himself. He was always reported to have a very good work ethic so one has to figure he was having problems dealing with failure. Hope he gets this sorted out because he always seemed like a fine young man.

[phillyesq]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Change the title to Grisham vs. Sweed and we can talk

I wouldn't be surprised if depression was Sweed's illness. I won't touch it because I think those 2 drops changed his career path. He can still bounce back but a ton of players spiral down real hard. It could be serious. Wallace emerging can't help his confidence either.

It wouldn't surprise me either. I hate to speculate, but it makes a lot of sense. The Steelers staying so tight-lipped about the situation lets us know that it is clearly something personal, and not football related. If it was a physical non-football injury, I don't think they'd be so tight lipped. I also read that he showed up to practice towards the end of the year, and I remember somebody (Santonio?) really seemed to emphasize that he was joking and laughing. Emphasizing laughter, etc. makes sense if Sweed was depressed.

As for Sweed vs. Edwards, the big difference is track record. Edwards has averaged 15.5 ypc for his career, and he has one monster season to his credit. I still haven't given up on Sweed, but next year is obviously his make or break season.

[ikestops85]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Ricky Williams suffers from depression

Vince Young suffers from depression

Limas Sweed suffers from depression?

We better not draft anymore of those UT players.


and put Tony Hill on a 24 hour watch also.

[RuthlessBurgher]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

Ricky Williams suffers from depression

Vince Young suffers from depression

Limas Sweed suffers from depression?

We better not draft anymore of those UT players.


and put Tony Hill on a 24 hour watch also.

Crap! I just changed my sig today with an uber-early mock draft (just to please all of the mock draft lovers we have around here), and my first round pick is a Longhorn! Now I'm depressed.

[NJ-STEELER]

Re: Sweed vs. Braylon Edwards

casey hampton is depressed























that he cant dance like william Gay