Randon Thoughts

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • steeler_george
    Hall of Famer
    • Dec 2008
    • 3417

    Randon Thoughts

    I have been blessed, cursed with a busy schedule the past few months too busy to post here, hell I didn't even watch one game of the Final Four Tourney, which I never miss. Even called days off work to watch or stayed up till 6 am ( time differnece Greece)

    With that said I have a few min. to post some random thoughts:

    1) Where is our draft guru, Steeler Keys? I love his input especially draft time.

    2) I love what we did in the FA, we have no true holes going tinto the draft. Our depth is stronger in all areas.

    3) As much as the media/fans keep suggesting we are drafting an OT early, I have a feeling we are going to draft one in the 3-4th rounds. Hell we might even draft a C or TE ( who can block) before OT. Bergeron and Breeland.

    4) Same can be said about CB, especially being a deep draft.

    5) If we follow the previous Steeler's FA-Draft Model, we sign FA as stopgaps to be replaced by draft picks. (ex) Barron>Bush, Ebron>Chasepool) I expect we go ILB, DL, and to a degre IOL (Center capble of playing Guard)

    My draft crushes: (same names, different order, and new flaovors, and there might be some reaches but will be gone by next pick)

    17 : WR JSN is #1 player on my board, then toss up between Branch, and Breese. Noel Smith as Timmons II is also tempting. As for CB, there seems to be too much depth, no clear cut player between Porter, Banks, Smith, Forbes, etc..
    32: All the above, add in ILB Sanders, Campbell, Simpson, WR Flowers, Addison, C Schmitz or Tippman. Same about CB...
    49: All the above, add in DL Beneton, Pickens, OT Bergeron, WR Mingo

    6) I kind of like this mock I did, first one where I had us skipping DL, OT, early or all together and added in playmakers for Kenny and an mammoth blocking TE for Najee.
    All 5 players could be starting 1st year or conribute this year, potentially starting next year.

    Traded 17 for 25 and 57
    25. Branch
    32. Flowers
    49. Wsshington TE
    57. Tippmann
    80. Bergeron
    120. Dorian Willians, Tulane ILB
    234 Karl , DL, Bowling Green

  • WindyCitySteel
    Legend
    • Nov 2011
    • 15684

    #2
    Stay away from this board if your draft dream comes true, it's going to be a mess.

    I think it's OT or CB in round 1, my guess is Porter since he seems to be the one in the most national mocks, and the Steelers kind of wear their first round pick on their sleeve all offseason.

    Comment

    • flippy
      Legend
      • Dec 2008
      • 17088

      #3
      I like a lot of the same guys as you. I really do think Branc and Breese migt be the guys available when we pick that are too good a value to pass on even though they aren't our top need and I would probably lean into taking either.
      sigpic

      Comment

      • Joel Buchsbaum
        Legend
        • Jan 2021
        • 7744

        #4
        Originally posted by steeler_george
        I have been blessed, cursed with a busy schedule the past few months too busy to post here, hell I didn't even watch one game of the Final Four Tourney, which I never miss. Even called days off work to watch or stayed up till 6 am ( time differnece Greece)

        With that said I have a few min. to post some random thoughts:

        1) Where is our draft guru, Steeler Keys? I love his input especially draft time.

        2) I love what we did in the FA, we have no true holes going tinto the draft. Our depth is stronger in all areas.

        3) As much as the media/fans keep suggesting we are drafting an OT early, I have a feeling we are going to draft one in the 3-4th rounds. Hell we might even draft a C or TE ( who can block) before OT. Bergeron and Breeland.

        4) Same can be said about CB, especially being a deep draft.

        5) If we follow the previous Steeler's FA-Draft Model, we sign FA as stopgaps to be replaced by draft picks. (ex) Barron>Bush, Ebron>Chasepool) I expect we go ILB, DL, and to a degre IOL (Center capble of playing Guard)

        My draft crushes: (same names, different order, and new flaovors, and there might be some reaches but will be gone by next pick)

        17 : WR JSN is #1 player on my board, then toss up between Branch, and Breese. Noel Smith as Timmons II is also tempting. As for CB, there seems to be too much depth, no clear cut player between Porter, Banks, Smith, Forbes, etc..
        32: All the above, add in ILB Sanders, Campbell, Simpson, WR Flowers, Addison, C Schmitz or Tippman. Same about CB...
        49: All the above, add in DL Beneton, Pickens, OT Bergeron, WR Mingo

        6) I kind of like this mock I did, first one where I had us skipping DL, OT, early or all together and added in playmakers for Kenny and an mammoth blocking TE for Najee.
        All 5 players could be starting 1st year or conribute this year, potentially starting next year.

        Traded 17 for 25 and 57
        25. Branch
        32. Flowers
        49. Wsshington TE
        57. Tippmann
        80. Bergeron
        120. Dorian Willians, Tulane ILB
        234 Karl , DL, Bowling Green
        Some one is going to have to explain to me WHY we spend a first round on a safety, that ran a 4.56 at the combine, and what a small WR will do for us who will be at best the third option at receiver ( 4th if you consider Muth )
        Tomlin hasn't won a playoff game in seven years and counting. The earliest will be eight years. I guess that in Art Rooney's II, opinion is worth a 3 year extension.

        Our 2024 draft looks to be grade A. Our 2023 draft is an A. The roster is talented, but Mike Tomlin is still the head coach.

        *** Mike Tomlin is the best coach since the AFL- NFL merger that has not won a playoff game in 8 seasons or more. It's either him or Lewis. ***

        Comment

        • SteelerOfDeVille
          Legend
          • May 2008
          • 9069

          #5
          Originally posted by Joel Buchsbaum
          Some one is going to have to explain to me WHY we spend a first round on a safety, that ran a 4.56 at the combine, and what a small WR will do for us who will be at best the third option at receiver ( 4th if you consider Muth )
          A strong safety running in the 4.5's isn't as big a deal as a CB running there. As a SS, you'll play him in the box some anyway - his tackling and quick reactions are the reason he's a 1st round prospect, NOT his ability to run stride for stride with a WR. He'll be covering TE and RB.

          HOWEVER, I think he'd be a good fit alongside Minkah who he wants to play next to (both being from Alabama). I think he'd follow Minkah like a puppy dog and end up with a crazy good work ethic. That situation would make him the best version of himself as a pro and he knows it. However since signing Keanu Neal, I don't see him as the best pick for the Steelers (yes... my sig is old)
          2013 MNF Executive Champion!

          Comment

          • LPMAN
            Pro Bowler
            • Sep 2021
            • 2042

            #6
            I really hope we get Bresee at #17. Last few years showed it to easy to run the ball down our throats. There were games teams ran out the clock on us Bettis style. That ain't Pittsburgh football! If Carter somehow slipped to #9 & we traded up i'd be estatic. If we get Addison or Porter i'll be just as happy but really i wish we'd use 3 of our 4 top 80 picks on offensive line & defensive line. We lost a lot of games in the trenches. We can go WR & CB high next year, take care of business this draft with the BIG UGLIES!

            If corner is so deep pick one in round 3 or 4 that needs developing ala Ike Taylor....

            Here's what i'd be happy with:

            #17 Bryan Bresee DT
            #32 Dawand Jones OT
            #49 Luke Wypler C
            #80 Clark Phillips III CB
            Last edited by LPMAN; 04-14-2023, 12:29 PM.

            Comment

            • SS Laser
              Pro Bowler
              • Apr 2009
              • 1929

              #7
              I don’t love the Branch pick. Prefer a true #1 corner drafted there.

              But I believe Cam Sutton ran his 40 in the 4.5x. So it’s not the end of the world. And I have read here and other places he could be a great slot cover guy. So if he is BPA I can’t complain, if he is better then Edmonds his rookie season. He fills a few needs.

              As far as WR, I am on the fence. Most of Bens career the Steelers used premium picks to stock up on WR’s for there QB. I love that. And figure it will continue for Kenny. Not sure Weidl’s history on WR and how that will affect Kahn though.

              Kind of like using a premium pick on a true blocking TE who could develop in as good as Muth in the passing game or even better.

              Concerning me is the latter rd OL as some have been flops lately.

              Also concerning me is late rd DL. Besides Cam there are not any premium picks on DL right now. Is the mid rd picks going to pan out or will the DL have to be rebuilt with FA soon like the OL? Has Tuitt even been really replaced yet? Can Larry O be that guy? Cams days are numbered at this point. Need a freaking stud DE/DT to replace him soon.

              Comment

              • whisper
                Legend
                • Mar 2020
                • 9423

                #8
                Originally posted by Joel Buchsbaum
                Some one is going to have to explain to me WHY we spend a first round on a safety, that ran a 4.56 at the combine, and what a small WR will do for us who will be at best the third option at receiver ( 4th if you consider Muth )
                5th if you consider Austin real and actually gonna contribute this season. Isn't it amazing how a player can go from "They guy who makes Canada's offensive system work" to being forgotten about in just 1 YEAR? My sense tells me they know he is too tiny to get it done already, with not even bothering to let him play when he said he was healthy last year.

                Comment

                • NorthCoast
                  Legend
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 26640

                  #9
                  Originally posted by steeler_george
                  I have been blessed, cursed with a busy schedule the past few months too busy to post here, hell I didn't even watch one game of the Final Four Tourney, which I never miss. Even called days off work to watch or stayed up till 6 am ( time differnece Greece)

                  With that said I have a few min. to post some random thoughts:

                  1) Where is our draft guru, Steeler Keys? I love his input especially draft time.

                  2) I love what we did in the FA, we have no true holes going tinto the draft. Our depth is stronger in all areas.

                  3) As much as the media/fans keep suggesting we are drafting an OT early, I have a feeling we are going to draft one in the 3-4th rounds. Hell we might even draft a C or TE ( who can block) before OT. Bergeron and Breeland.

                  4) Same can be said about CB, especially being a deep draft.

                  5) If we follow the previous Steeler's FA-Draft Model, we sign FA as stopgaps to be replaced by draft picks. (ex) Barron>Bush, Ebron>Chasepool) I expect we go ILB, DL, and to a degre IOL (Center capble of playing Guard)

                  My draft crushes: (same names, different order, and new flaovors, and there might be some reaches but will be gone by next pick)

                  17 : WR JSN is #1 player on my board, then toss up between Branch, and Breese. Noel Smith as Timmons II is also tempting. As for CB, there seems to be too much depth, no clear cut player between Porter, Banks, Smith, Forbes, etc..
                  32: All the above, add in ILB Sanders, Campbell, Simpson, WR Flowers, Addison, C Schmitz or Tippman. Same about CB...
                  49: All the above, add in DL Beneton, Pickens, OT Bergeron, WR Mingo

                  6) I kind of like this mock I did, first one where I had us skipping DL, OT, early or all together and added in playmakers for Kenny and an mammoth blocking TE for Najee.
                  All 5 players could be starting 1st year or conribute this year, potentially starting next year.

                  Traded 17 for 25 and 57
                  25. Branch
                  32. Flowers
                  49. Wsshington TE
                  57. Tippmann
                  80. Bergeron
                  120. Dorian Willians, Tulane ILB
                  234 Karl , DL, Bowling Green
                  In the past regime I might agree with some of what you say but it's clear there is "something different" with Kahn and Weidl in charge. Whole lot of uncertainty about where their priorities might be.

                  Comment

                  • steeler_george
                    Hall of Famer
                    • Dec 2008
                    • 3417

                    #10
                    Originally posted by WindyCitySteel
                    Stay away from this board if your draft dream comes true, it's going to be a mess.

                    I think it's OT or CB in round 1, my guess is Porter since he seems to be the one in the most national mocks, and the Steelers kind of wear their first round pick on their sleeve all offseason.
                    Where do i say draft dream....?

                    Just a mock draft where i was messing around, and acually thought it looks like a good match to our needs. As in most mocks, you hope the players hit that ceiling you hope for.

                    If it was my dream draft I would love to end up with NJS WR, Breese DL, Branch slot/SS, and Sanders/Campbell as ILB., and one of the top 3 CB.
                    Last edited by steeler_george; 04-14-2023, 01:21 PM. Reason: adding more info

                    Comment

                    • Captain Lemming
                      Legend
                      • Jun 2008
                      • 16063

                      #11
                      Originally posted by steeler_george
                      I have been blessed, cursed with a busy schedule the past few months too busy to post here, hell I didn't even watch one game of the Final Four Tourney, which I never miss. Even called days off work to watch or stayed up till 6 am ( time differnece Greece)

                      With that said I have a few min. to post some random thoughts:

                      1) Where is our draft guru, Steeler Keys? I love his input especially draft time.

                      2) I love what we did in the FA, we have no true holes going tinto the draft. Our depth is stronger in all areas.

                      3) As much as the media/fans keep suggesting we are drafting an OT early, I have a feeling we are going to draft one in the 3-4th rounds. Hell we might even draft a C or TE ( who can block) before OT. Bergeron and Breeland.

                      4) Same can be said about CB, especially being a deep draft.

                      5) If we follow the previous Steeler's FA-Draft Model, we sign FA as stopgaps to be replaced by draft picks. (ex) Barron>Bush, Ebron>Chasepool) I expect we go ILB, DL, and to a degre IOL (Center capble of playing Guard)

                      My draft crushes: (same names, different order, and new flaovors, and there might be some reaches but will be gone by next pick)

                      17 : WR JSN is #1 player on my board, then toss up between Branch, and Breese. Noel Smith as Timmons II is also tempting. As for CB, there seems to be too much depth, no clear cut player between Porter, Banks, Smith, Forbes, etc..
                      32: All the above, add in ILB Sanders, Campbell, Simpson, WR Flowers, Addison, C Schmitz or Tippman. Same about CB...
                      49: All the above, add in DL Beneton, Pickens, OT Bergeron, WR Mingo

                      6) I kind of like this mock I did, first one where I had us skipping DL, OT, early or all together and added in playmakers for Kenny and an mammoth blocking TE for Najee.
                      All 5 players could be starting 1st year or conribute this year, potentially starting next year.

                      Traded 17 for 25 and 57
                      25. Branch
                      32. Flowers
                      49. Wsshington TE
                      57. Tippmann
                      80. Bergeron
                      120. Dorian Willians, Tulane ILB
                      234 Karl , DL, Bowling Green
                      Depth at corner is a great reason not to draft a good one in all that depth?
                      sigpic



                      In view of the fact that Mike Tomlin has matched Cowhers record I give him the designation:

                      TCFCLTC-
                      The Coach Formerly Considered Less Than Cowher

                      Comment

                      • Captain Lemming
                        Legend
                        • Jun 2008
                        • 16063

                        #12
                        Originally posted by SteelerOfDeVille
                        A strong safety running in the 4.5's isn't as big a deal as a CB running there. As a SS, you'll play him in the box some anyway - his tackling and quick reactions are the reason he's a 1st round prospect, NOT his ability to run stride for stride with a WR. He'll be covering TE and RB.

                        HOWEVER, I think he'd be a good fit alongside Minkah who he wants to play next to (both being from Alabama). I think he'd follow Minkah like a puppy dog and end up with a crazy good work ethic. That situation would make him the best version of himself as a pro and he knows it. However since signing Keanu Neal, I don't see him as the best pick for the Steelers (yes... my sig is old)
                        I love your current mock but Banks ain’t gonna be there at 2a. Not a chance.
                        sigpic



                        In view of the fact that Mike Tomlin has matched Cowhers record I give him the designation:

                        TCFCLTC-
                        The Coach Formerly Considered Less Than Cowher

                        Comment

                        • pfelix73
                          Hall of Famer
                          • Aug 2008
                          • 3463

                          #13
                          Originally posted by steeler_george
                          I have been blessed, cursed with a busy schedule the past few months too busy to post here, hell I didn't even watch one game of the Final Four Tourney, which I never miss. Even called days off work to watch or stayed up till 6 am ( time differnece Greece)

                          With that said I have a few min. to post some random thoughts:

                          1) Where is our draft guru, Steeler Keys? I love his input especially draft time.

                          2) I love what we did in the FA, we have no true holes going tinto the draft. Our depth is stronger in all areas.

                          3) As much as the media/fans keep suggesting we are drafting an OT early, I have a feeling we are going to draft one in the 3-4th rounds. Hell we might even draft a C or TE ( who can block) before OT. Bergeron and Breeland.

                          4) Same can be said about CB, especially being a deep draft.

                          5) If we follow the previous Steeler's FA-Draft Model, we sign FA as stopgaps to be replaced by draft picks. (ex) Barron>Bush, Ebron>Chasepool) I expect we go ILB, DL, and to a degre IOL (Center capble of playing Guard)

                          My draft crushes: (same names, different order, and new flaovors, and there might be some reaches but will be gone by next pick)

                          17 : WR JSN is #1 player on my board, then toss up between Branch, and Breese. Noel Smith as Timmons II is also tempting. As for CB, there seems to be too much depth, no clear cut player between Porter, Banks, Smith, Forbes, etc..
                          32: All the above, add in ILB Sanders, Campbell, Simpson, WR Flowers, Addison, C Schmitz or Tippman. Same about CB...
                          49: All the above, add in DL Beneton, Pickens, OT Bergeron, WR Mingo

                          6) I kind of like this mock I did, first one where I had us skipping DL, OT, early or all together and added in playmakers for Kenny and an mammoth blocking TE for Najee.
                          All 5 players could be starting 1st year or conribute this year, potentially starting next year.

                          Traded 17 for 25 and 57
                          25. Branch
                          32. Flowers
                          49. Wsshington TE
                          57. Tippmann
                          80. Bergeron
                          120. Dorian Willians, Tulane ILB
                          234 Karl , DL, Bowling Green
                          I like it. I've said all along that we might be surprised on this one. Surprised meaning TE somewhere early. Washington is a beast and can block.
                          6- Time Super Bowl Champions......
                          IX X XIII XIV XL XLIII

                          2012 MNF Executive Champion

                          sigpic



                          Comment

                          • pfelix73
                            Hall of Famer
                            • Aug 2008
                            • 3463

                            #14
                            Originally posted by flippy
                            I like a lot of the same guys as you. I really do think Branc and Breese migt be the guys available when we pick that are too good a value to pass on even though they aren't our top need and I would probably lean into taking either.
                            How do you know that those 2 aren't our top needs? Because of what you see and read on FB and in the press? We have a need on the DL. We need depth and Cam isn't getting any younger. We have need at Safety too. More so than OL.
                            6- Time Super Bowl Champions......
                            IX X XIII XIV XL XLIII

                            2012 MNF Executive Champion

                            sigpic



                            Comment

                            • Joel Buchsbaum
                              Legend
                              • Jan 2021
                              • 7744

                              #15
                              Originally posted by SteelerOfDeVille
                              A strong safety running in the 4.5's isn't as big a deal as a CB running there. As a SS, you'll play him in the box some anyway - his tackling and quick reactions are the reason he's a 1st round prospect, NOT his ability to run stride for stride with a WR. He'll be covering TE and RB.

                              HOWEVER, I think he'd be a good fit alongside Minkah who he wants to play next to (both being from Alabama). I think he'd follow Minkah like a puppy dog and end up with a crazy good work ethic. That situation would make him the best version of himself as a pro and he knows it. However since signing Keanu Neal, I don't see him as the best pick for the Steelers (yes... my sig is old)

                              My issue with drafting him is where have bigger needs in round one. I agree he upgrade us, but not as much as say a tackle or cornerback in round one. Call me crazy but I think RB is a need more than S.
                              Tomlin hasn't won a playoff game in seven years and counting. The earliest will be eight years. I guess that in Art Rooney's II, opinion is worth a 3 year extension.

                              Our 2024 draft looks to be grade A. Our 2023 draft is an A. The roster is talented, but Mike Tomlin is still the head coach.

                              *** Mike Tomlin is the best coach since the AFL- NFL merger that has not won a playoff game in 8 seasons or more. It's either him or Lewis. ***

                              Comment

                              Working...