Mingo or Jones?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SteelCrazy
    Legend
    • Aug 2008
    • 5057

    Mingo or Jones?

    The last two linebackers to win NFL Defensive Player of the Year came from AFC North. James Harrison of the Pittsburgh Steelers received the honor in 2008, and Terrell Suggs of the Baltimore Ravens followed him in 2011.

    Who's the next great pass-rusher in the division? Look no further than the first round of this year's NFL draft. The Cleveland Browns selected LSU's Barkevious Mingo with the No. 6 overall pick, and the Steelers chose Georgia's Jarvis Jones at No. 17.

    If you're asking which one is the better pass-rusher, you'll need to be more specific. Jones is the better pass-rusher right now. Mingo has the potential to be the better one in four years.

    Jones led the nation with 14.5 sacks in 2012 despite missing two games. He can step into Harrison's spot immediately. Mingo is freakishly athletic with an explosive first step and exceptional closing speed. He could be the next Jevon Kearse.

    Comparing Mingo and Jones will continue throughout their careers. They both played in the Southeastern Conference. They both have major questions to answer about whether they can last in the NFL. And they both ended up on AFC North rivals who are within a 2.5-hour drive of each other.

    "The difference is Jones may have already maxed out his ability to get to the quarterback while Mingo is just scratching the surface," said Steve Muench of Scouts Inc.

    Whatever your thoughts about where Mingo and Jones stand in their development, they were the perfect picks for their teams. Every move the Browns make is with an eye to the future. That became clear when Cleveland traded two of this year's seven draft picks for ones in 2014. Mingo is that unpolished playmaker who can grow with the Browns defense.

    The Browns are making the transition from a 4-3 defense to a 3-4 scheme, which is exactly what Mingo will be doing. He'll be switching from a college defensive end to an NFL outside linebacker. He'll need time to add the upper-body strength needed to get off blocks. At 237 pounds, he looks more like a cross between a wide receiver and tight end than a linebacker.

    Cleveland doesn't have to rush Mingo because it has Paul Kruger, Jabaal Sheard and Quentin Groves. The hope is Mingo will develop into a dominant pass-rusher by the time more pieces are in place. He has the height (6-foot-4), wingspan, agility and competitive attitude to become a special player.

    The biggest knocks on Mingo are he’s a workout wonder and his college production didn't warrant a top-10 pick. Mingo had only 4.5 sacks last season at LSU and just 12.5 over his past two seasons. But he did record 28 total pressures in 2012 (hurries and knockdowns), which tied him for second in the SEC.

    "One of the things you look at is not just sack totals, but disrupting, affecting and putting pressure on the quarterback," Browns coach Rob Chudzinski said. "As you watch games and you study him, he had a lot of snaps where he did that, and it wasn’t necessarily equating to sacks but the pressures on the quarterback, the batted balls, just making quarterbacks step up, slide and have to throw on the move. He had a number of those."

    When it came to choosing between Mingo and Jones, Cleveland didn't think there was a decision. In hindsight, the Browns could have had Jones and two additional picks (in the second and seventh rounds) if they traded down to No. 16 with the St. Louis Rams. Cleveland refused because Mingo was one of four blue-chippers that team officials had identified.

    After the Browns selected Mingo at No. 6, the next pass-rusher drafted was Jones, 11 spots later. Mingo acknowledged he was surprised that Jones fell so far in the first round.

    "But the coaches here obviously knew what they wanted in a player and as a person," Mingo said. "I think they made the right decision, obviously, and I’m just thrilled to be here.”

    The Steelers were equally thrilled to see Jones at their spot. Pittsburgh needed a pass-rusher who can provide instant results because its defense is built to win now. Three of the four starting defensive backs are 32 years old or older: cornerback Ike Taylor and safeties Troy Polamalu and Ryan Clark. Two of the three starting defensive linemen are entering the final years of their contracts: defensive ends Brett Keisel and Ziggy Hood.

    Unlike Mingo, there's less of a learning curve with Jones. He played outside linebacker in a pro-style 3-4 scheme at Georgia, and he talked about recognizing familiar concepts while flipping through the Steelers' playbook last weekend. Jones led the SEC with 31 quarterback pressures and had 15 hurries (defined as a play where the quarterback was flushed out of the pocket or hurried his throw due to pressure), the most of any draft-eligible prospect.

    "He is a violent hand fighter who can beat offensive linemen one-on-one," Muench said. "He is relentless, and even though he didn’t run well at his pro day, he closes well on tape. He’ll make an impact at the next level if he can stay healthy."

    That's the key -- staying healthy. Jones transferred from Southern California after the 2009 season because doctors wouldn't clear him to play. They diagnosed him with spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal column. It's a condition that has shortened the careers of top players, including offensive tackle Marcus McNeill, who retired after six seasons.

    "We're very comfortable with his medical status or we wouldn't have made that pick," Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert said.

    So who will be the better pass-rusher? It depends on your point of view. Jones will be delivering more hits on Joe Flacco and Andy Dalton this season, but Mingo may end up with more career hits. In the end, the Steelers and Browns got the players they wanted. It's up to Jones and Mingo to prove their teams were right.

    [url]http://espn.go.com/blog/afcnorth/post/_/id/70003/next-best-pass-rusher-mingo-or-jones[/url]
    2019 Mock

    1. ILB
    2. CB
    3. ILB
    4. S
    5. CB
    6. ILB
    7. S
  • steelz09
    Administrator
    • Jan 2008
    • 4675

    #2
    Mingo - Better athlete than football player

    Jones - Better football player than athlete

    Last time I checked, this game was football and they play in pads. Give me the better football player any day.
    Tomlin: Let's unleash hell and "mop the floor" with the competition.

    Comment

    • flippy
      Legend
      • Dec 2008
      • 17088

      #3
      Mingo woulda been Al Davis' choice.
      sigpic

      Comment

      • SteelCrazy
        Legend
        • Aug 2008
        • 5057

        #4
        The thing about Mingo is his athleticism put him in position a lot, but he rarely came away with making the play. When Jones gets in position, he makes the play. Sure, Mingo has a better upside, but its only because he rarely made a play and yet was so close. Jones is closer to perfection, so he isnt going to have much room to get better.

        Folks, we got Lawrence Taylor #2. If he stays healthy for the next 10 years we may be discussing who was better, #1 or #2.
        2019 Mock

        1. ILB
        2. CB
        3. ILB
        4. S
        5. CB
        6. ILB
        7. S

        Comment

        • Shoe
          Hall of Famer
          • May 2008
          • 4044

          #5
          Originally posted by SteelCrazy
          The thing about Mingo is his athleticism put him in position a lot, but he rarely came away with making the play. When Jones gets in position, he makes the play. Sure, Mingo has a better upside, but its only because he rarely made a play and yet was so close. Jones is closer to perfection, so he isnt going to have much room to get better.

          Folks, we got Lawrence Taylor #2. If he stays healthy for the next 10 years we may be discussing who was better, #1 or #2.
          You really are CRAZY, if you are comparing Jarvis Jones to Lawrence Taylor.
          I wasn't hired for my disposition.

          Comment

          • ikestops85
            Hall of Famer
            • Jun 2008
            • 3724

            #6
            Originally posted by Shoe
            You really are CRAZY, if you are comparing Jarvis Jones to Lawrence Taylor.
            I don't think he is crazy. I would love if 8 - 10 years down the road people were comparing Jones to Taylor. Like they say, if you are going to dream then dream big. Coming out of college Jones has a pedigree as good as, if not better, than Clay Matthews and Von Miller. Why can't he be the next GOAT linebacker? I am certainly rooting for it.
            As many on this site think ... The Rooney's suck, Colbert sucks, Tomlin sucks, the coaches suck, and the players suck.

            but Go Steelers!!!

            Comment

            • flippy
              Legend
              • Dec 2008
              • 17088

              #7
              Originally posted by ikestops85
              I don't think he is crazy. I would love if 8 - 10 years down the road people were comparing Jones to Taylor. Like they say, if you are going to dream then dream big. Coming out of college Jones has a pedigree as good as, if not better, than Clay Matthews and Von Miller. Why can't he be the next GOAT linebacker? I am certainly rooting for it.
              I can't wait to see what he becomes in a year or 2. Will he be 260-270 after he works out as a pro?
              sigpic

              Comment

              • SteelSpain
                Backup
                • Apr 2013
                • 269

                #8
                I have a question:

                If Jarvis Jones does not start this year or the next and does not put 10+ sacks in both years, can we call him "Jarbust" Jones?
                Steeler Nation in Spain

                Comment

                • SteelerOfDeVille
                  Legend
                  • May 2008
                  • 9069

                  #9
                  Originally posted by steelz09
                  Mingo - Better athlete than football player

                  Jones - Better football player than athlete

                  Last time I checked, this game was football and they play in pads. Give me the better football player any day.
                  couldn't have said it better, myself.
                  2013 MNF Executive Champion!

                  Comment

                  • Ghost
                    Legend
                    • May 2008
                    • 6423

                    #10
                    "The difference is Jones may have already maxed out his ability to get to the quarterback while Mingo is just scratching the surface," said Steve Muench of Scouts Inc.

                    I have no idea how he came to this conclusion? Pure speculation and you could exchange the names in the statement and it's be just as unprovable as stated above. At this point, the ONLY thing to compare is who was a better football player and that was Jones, playing in the same conference as Mingo. And how does he know Mingo can switch positions successfully? Sitting her in May, this is a silly statement.



                    sigpic

                    Comment

                    • SteelSpain
                      Backup
                      • Apr 2013
                      • 269

                      #11
                      If we had drafted Mingo I would not be relaxed...
                      Steeler Nation in Spain

                      Comment

                      • RuthlessBurgher
                        Legend
                        • May 2008
                        • 33208

                        #12
                        The Browns REALLY should have traded back with St. Louis if they were smart. Luckily, they are not smart, so we benefit. Then they could have re-couped the 2nd round pick they gave up in last year's supplemental draft, plus gained an extra 7th round pick. Buffalo used those picks to take ILB Kiko Alonso and TE Chris Gragg. Would the Browns be better off with Mingo, or with Jones, Alonso, and Gragg?

                        Actually, looking at who was available with the pick Buffalo got from the Rams, Cleveland could have taken a better CB prospect to start opposite Haden than Leon McFadden who they picked in the 3rd round (Jamar Taylor and David Amerson were both available), and then they could have used their 3rd round pick on BPA instead of reaching to fill a need at corner (WR Keenan Allen was available where they were picking in round 3; think he'd be helpful on their roster to team up with Josh Gordan and Greg Little?).

                        Just think...the Browns could have had OLB Jarvis Jones, CB Jamar Taylor, and WR Keenan Allen if they made that trade (plus, they would have screwed us out of the guy we wanted in round 1)...instead they got OLB Barkevious Mingo and CB Leon McFadden (and we got Jarvis Jones). Cleveland sucks. I'm certainly glad they do.
                        Steeler teams featuring stat-driven, me-first, fantasy-football-darling diva types such as Antonio Brown & Le'Veon Bell won no championships.

                        Super Bowl winning Steeler teams were built around a dynamic, in-your-face defense plus blue-collar, hard-hitting, no-nonsense football players on offense such as Hines Ward & Jerome Bettis.

                        We don't want Juju & Conner to replace what we lost in Brown & Bell.

                        We are counting on Juju & Conner to return us to the glory we once had with Hines & The Bus.

                        Comment

                        • SteelSpain
                          Backup
                          • Apr 2013
                          • 269

                          #13
                          Originally posted by RuthlessBurgher
                          The Browns REALLY should have traded back with St. Louis if they were smart. Luckily, they are not smart, so we benefit. Then they could have re-couped the 2nd round pick they gave up in last year's supplemental draft, plus gained an extra 7th round pick. Buffalo used those picks to take ILB Kiko Alonso and TE Chris Gragg. Would the Browns be better off with Mingo, or with Jones, Alonso, and Gragg?

                          Actually, looking at who was available with the pick Buffalo got from the Rams, Cleveland could have taken a better CB prospect to start opposite Haden than Leon McFadden who they picked in the 3rd round (Jamar Taylor and David Amerson were both available), and then they could have used their 3rd round pick on BPA instead of reaching to fill a need at corner (WR Keenan Allen was available where they were picking in round 3; think he'd be helpful on their roster to team up with Josh Gordan and Greg Little?).

                          Just think...the Browns could have had OLB Jarvis Jones, CB Jamar Taylor, and WR Keenan Allen if they made that trade (plus, they would have screwed us out of the guy we wanted in round 1)...instead they got OLB Barkevious Mingo and CB Leon McFadden (and we got Jarvis Jones). Cleveland sucks. I'm certainly glad they do.
                          If they did that, they are not selecting almost every year in the Top 10 and they would not be the Cleveland Browns.
                          Steeler Nation in Spain

                          Comment

                          • flippy
                            Legend
                            • Dec 2008
                            • 17088

                            #14
                            Originally posted by RuthlessBurgher
                            The Browns REALLY should have traded back with St. Louis if they were smart. Luckily, they are not smart, so we benefit. Then they could have re-couped the 2nd round pick they gave up in last year's supplemental draft, plus gained an extra 7th round pick. Buffalo used those picks to take ILB Kiko Alonso and TE Chris Gragg. Would the Browns be better off with Mingo, or with Jones, Alonso, and Gragg?

                            Actually, looking at who was available with the pick Buffalo got from the Rams, Cleveland could have taken a better CB prospect to start opposite Haden than Leon McFadden who they picked in the 3rd round (Jamar Taylor and David Amerson were both available), and then they could have used their 3rd round pick on BPA instead of reaching to fill a need at corner (WR Keenan Allen was available where they were picking in round 3; think he'd be helpful on their roster to team up with Josh Gordan and Greg Little?).

                            Just think...the Browns could have had OLB Jarvis Jones, CB Jamar Taylor, and WR Keenan Allen if they made that trade (plus, they would have screwed us out of the guy we wanted in round 1)...instead they got OLB Barkevious Mingo and CB Leon McFadden (and we got Jarvis Jones). Cleveland sucks. I'm certainly glad they do.
                            I'm glad we have you in the wings for when Colbert is done.
                            sigpic

                            Comment

                            • SteelCrazy
                              Legend
                              • Aug 2008
                              • 5057

                              #15
                              This is every snap against Florida. Impressive

                              2019 Mock

                              1. ILB
                              2. CB
                              3. ILB
                              4. S
                              5. CB
                              6. ILB
                              7. S

                              Comment

                              Working...