Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

[focosteeler]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Question for you guys, if phil taylor made it to 25 and all the 1st round tackles, DE and pouncey and corners were gone...would you be ok with us trading with seattle to get him? Or rather trade back to early second

[hawaiiansteel]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Question for you guys, if phil taylor made it to 25 and all the 1st round tackles, DE and pouncey and corners were gone...would you be ok with us trading with seattle to get him? Or rather trade back to early second

I would not want to give up our 1st and 3rd for Phil Taylor.

I would much rather trade down and pick up extra draft choices in a very deep draft and in a year when draft picks are possibly more valuable than ever.

[Shawn]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Question for you guys, if phil taylor made it to 25 and all the 1st round tackles, DE and pouncey and corners were gone...would you be ok with us trading with seattle to get him? Or rather trade back to early second

Absolutely.

[Chadman]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Is Phil Taylor a lock to be worthy of 2 draft picks?


Personal choice, but Chadman would be reluctant to give up picks for him. He's a fine player- and possibly worthy of #31- but worthy of the 3rd round selection as well?

Is he Casey Hampton + Mike Wallace worthy?

[Shawn]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Is Phil Taylor a lock to be worthy of 2 draft picks?


Personal choice, but Chadman would be reluctant to give up picks for him. He's a fine player- and possibly worthy of #31- but worthy of the 3rd round selection as well?

Is he Casey Hampton + Mike Wallace worthy?

No, but he is Jermaine Stephens + Bruce Davis worthy.

[focosteeler]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Is Phil Taylor a lock to be worthy of 2 draft picks?


Personal choice, but Chadman would be reluctant to give up picks for him. He's a fine player- and possibly worthy of #31- but worthy of the 3rd round selection as well?

Is he Casey Hampton + Mike Wallace worthy?

that is the question....if only i could see into the future...i would be one bad a$$ GM

[Chadman]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

It's all a gamble in the end...but risk/reward for Taylor doesn't seem right to give up 2 picks for him.

Chadman could be WAY off though- it has happened before.

[steeler_fan_in_t.o.]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Is Phil Taylor a lock to be worthy of 2 draft picks?


Personal choice, but Chadman would be reluctant to give up picks for him. He's a fine player- and possibly worthy of #31- but worthy of the 3rd round selection as well?

Is he Casey Hampton + Mike Wallace worthy?

No, but he is Jermaine Stephens + Bruce Davis worthy.

Shawn.........

You would be Stephens and Davis worthy.

[Chadman]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Chadman would trade Shawn, Jamain Stephens & Bruce Davis for a 6th round pick.

Shawn would probably draw the strength of the trade value.

[steeler_fan_in_t.o.]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Add Florida T Marcus Gilbert to the list:

[url="http://www.steelersdepot.com/2011/03/florida-t-marcus-gilbert-fsu-g-rodney-hudson-reportedly-will-visit-steelers/"]http://www.steelersdepot.com/2011/03/fl ... -steelers/[/url]

[Chadman]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Got bagged for suggesting Gilbert as a 2nd round pick- but he's a long term starter- played both OT positions & has familiarity with one Maurkice Pouncey.

His body size/shape is very similar to Max Starks.

If he was the 2nd round pick, Chadman could happily live with that.

[Shawn]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Chadman would trade Shawn, Jamain Stephens & Bruce Davis for a 6th round pick.

Shawn would probably draw the strength of the trade value.

My wife would probably trade me for a pudding pop and foot rub.

[Shawn]

Re: Pre-draft visit -- Phil Taylor & Rodney Hudson

Is Phil Taylor a lock to be worthy of 2 draft picks?


Personal choice, but Chadman would be reluctant to give up picks for him. He's a fine player- and possibly worthy of #31- but worthy of the 3rd round selection as well?

Is he Casey Hampton + Mike Wallace worthy?

No, but he is Jermaine Stephens + Bruce Davis worthy.

Shawn.........

You would be Stephens and Davis worthy.

You have a point.