Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

[Scalaid6]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

The Steelers were bad due to SCHEME (passing). The Colts were bad due to LACK OF TALENT.

GET IT?

So the Colts went to the AFC title game in 1995, and back to the playoffs in 1996 prior to Peyton's 1998 arrival and yet they didn't have talent? If you say so.

That was WITH FAULK. They suffered without him. My point is PEYTON MANNING IS THE PRIMARY REASON the Colts are elite.

OUR DEFENSE if the PRIMARY reason we are- NOT BEN

[Crash]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

Brees 34-44 305 Yds 2 TD 1 Int

And a fumble lost. Can't forget that.

Who had the ELITE game in your opinion?

NEITHER.

[Crash]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

I'm sure you think those are the reasons and I am as sure you think you are 100% correct.

Ask him. He can't keep his mouth shut so IMO he would admit it.

[Scalaid6]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

Brees 34-44 305 Yds 2 TD 1 Int

And a fumble lost. Can't forget that.

[quote:2qmo9s9i]Who had the ELITE game in your opinion?

NEITHER.[/quote:2qmo9s9i]

A fumble lost? Ben had 17 TDS AND 15 INTS AND EIGHT FUMBLES lost and won a Super Bowl in 08. Thats TWENTY THREE TURNOVERS BY THE QB.

Brees played better than Ben

Brees completed SEVENTY SEVEN % of his passes and had a 101 rating

Ben had a SIXTY SIX rating.

KEEP SHOWING YOUR COLORS HOMER

LOL

[grotonsteel]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

So Rivers should have won SB according to your logic?? He has all the POINTS and PRODUCTION.


BTW how did Ben play against Cheatroits???

Again go watch a NFL game before opening your trap.

IF He was on the Steelers he would have. So would Dan Marino (a guy who sucks according to your logic) You give guys like Dilfer, Brad Johnson and Jeff Hostettler bonuses for winning the big game and shoot down gunslingers like Kelly, Marino, Tarkenton and Fouts because they didnt. They are STILL great qbs in their own rights.

Ben played TERRIBLE vs the cheatriots UNTIL they went prevent.[/quote]




Have you ever watched an NFL game in your life???

Rivers had a Top-5 Defense. So shove your argument that Rivers would have won on Steelers team.He can't freaking take his team to playoff in a weak division with a Top-5 Defense in NFL.

Rivers scored garbage points and if you watched NFL games maybe you might figure it out. Stop clicking on Yahoo box score.

Why would you say Ben played terrible against Cheatroits??? He has POINTS and PRODUCTION.

So you get my point. FANTASY FOOTBALL is not everything.

Again you failed to answer is 33-22 TD/INT better than 17-5 TD/INT with 3000 yards in 12 games???

[Crash]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

So you feel the talent on the 1998 Colts is equal to the 2004 Steelers?

If the 2004 Steelers had all this talent why did they miss the playoffs 4 of the previous 6 seasons before Ben?

And why do you completely switch your standards when discussing Peyton versus Ben?

It's you anti-Ben Peyton ball lickers who who change the rules just like Manning's media pals do.

[Crash]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

Brees played better than Ben

The question asked was who had the elite GAME, not who played better of the two QBs during it.

Neither had an elite game.

[grotonsteel]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

The Steelers were bad due to SCHEME (passing). The Colts were bad due to LACK OF TALENT.

GET IT?

So the Colts went to the AFC title game in 1995, and back to the playoffs in 1996 prior to Peyton's 1998 arrival and yet they didn't have talent? If you say so.

That was WITH FAULK. They suffered without him. My point is PEYTON MANNING IS THE PRIMARY REASON the Colts are elite.

OUR DEFENSE if the PRIMARY reason we are- NOT BEN

Steelers spend 70% of their salary cap on Defense. Why should you not expect Defense to play better than offense. Its completely reverse on Colts team.

Oh BTW the season Colts won SB..Peyton has 1 TD- 4 INT in the playoff run. Just saying.

[Scalaid6]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

So Rivers should have won SB according to your logic?? He has all the POINTS and PRODUCTION.


BTW how did Ben play against Cheatroits???

Again go watch a NFL game before opening your trap.

IF He was on the Steelers he would have. So would Dan Marino (a guy who sucks according to your logic) You give guys like Dilfer, Brad Johnson and Jeff Hostettler bonuses for winning the big game and shoot down gunslingers like Kelly, Marino, Tarkenton and Fouts because they didnt. They are STILL great qbs in their own rights.

Ben played TERRIBLE vs the cheatriots UNTIL they went prevent.

Have you ever watched an NFL game in your life???

Rivers had a Top-5 Defense. So shove your argument that Rivers would have won on Steelers team.He can't freaking take his team to playoff in a weak division with a Top-5 Defense in NFL.

Rivers scored garbage points and if you watched NFL games maybe you might figure it out. Stop clicking on Yahoo box score.

Why would you say Ben played terrible against Cheatroits??? He has POINTS and PRODUCTION.

So you get my point. FANTASY FOOTBALL is not everything.

Again you failed to answer is 33-22 TD/INT better than 17-5 TD/INT with 3000 yards in 12 games???[/quote]

Rivers doesnt have a Mendenhall. WHY did Rivers get drafted BEFORE Ben?
Probably because he IS BETTER.

Rivers is a productive qb do you think that production would stop on the Steelers? I dont.

Ben got those points and production vs THE PREVENT as stated earlier. Prior to that PREVENT he produced THREE POINTS.

NEXT EXCUSE?

[Scalaid6]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

So you feel the talent on the 1998 Colts is equal to the 2004 Steelers?

If the 2004 Steelers had all this talent why did they miss the playoffs 4 of the previous 6 seasons before Ben?

[quote:13fx5nle]And why do you completely switch your standards when discussing Peyton versus Ben?

It's you anti-Ben Peyton ball lickers who who change the rules just like Manning's media pals do.[/quote:13fx5nle]


I never said ANYTHING about our talent in 04. Ben won all those games THANKS TO THE RUNNING GAME.
When we needed Ben to PASS in the AFCCG what happened?

HE FAILED

[Blockhead]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

If the 2004 Steelers had all this talent why did they miss the playoffs 4 of the previous 6 seasons before Ben?

Don't pose a question back to a question. Answer the question. You proclaim to be expert everything when it comes to the Steelers so I would expect you to know the reasons we fell short in 2004.

It's you anti-Ben Peyton ball lickers who who change the rules just like Manning's media pals do.

It seems to me the only one reversing criteria and using excuses in lieu of presented facts is yourself. You have proven to be completely uninformed and yet, when informed, still refuse to admit to facts.

I await your answer to the above posted question.

[Scalaid6]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

Brees played better than Ben

The question asked was who had the elite GAME, not who played better of the two QBs during it.

Neither had an elite game.

So why cant you list FOUR GAMES IN A ROW WHERE BEN ROETHLISBERGER HAS PRODUCED ELITE STATS?

I'll tell you why you can because HE HASNT DONE IT. This is PROOF that he is inconsistent as heck.

You have 7 years. Please list FOUR IN A ROW

I'LL WAIT

[Crash]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

Rivers doesnt have a Mendenhall

No, he only had sure fire HOF LT for four seasons and still couldn't win a ring.

Btw, Ben won two rings WITHOUT Mendenhall.

This is too easy, make an EFFORT.

[Blockhead]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

Rivers doesnt have a Mendenhall

No, he only had sure fire HOF LT for four seasons and still couldn't win a ring.

Btw, Ben won two rings WITHOUT Mendenhall.

This is too easy, make an EFFORT.

And Peyton Manning lost a first ballot HOF'er and yet you suggest the talent in 1998 Colts is compareable to 2004 Steelers?

Criteria changing again? That's twice in one thread you have used the same criteria to support Ben yet bash Peyton and Philip?

Inconsistent much?

[Crash]

Re: Little Ben Is Inconsistent, the Truth Hurts

When we needed Ben to PASS in the AFCCG what happened?

They were down 24-3 and were on the verge of cutting it to seven points before Cowher decided to run the ball again and then kick a 20 yard field goal down 31-17.

That game is exactly what I and others talk about. For most of the first half they did what you clowns wanted and tried to run the ball.

Fell behind 17-3 doing it.