Reed or Polamalu?

[Iron Shiek]

Re: Reed or Polamalu?

Troy was pretty quiet today. They played him way off the line but even in coverage and that terrible attempt at tackling Rice was not troy-esque. We need him to step up next sunday!

[ikestops85]

Re: Reed or Polamalu?

I think Woodson is right about picking Reed to start a team. Reed plays a true FS position and is excellent at it. Troy plays a position that is unique in the NFL. There isn't another player in the world who does what Troy does. He is a guy who is great at run stopping, blitzing and being a ball hawk. He might not be the greatest in any of those areas but that he is great in ALL those areas in my mind makes him the better player.

[ALLD]

Re: Reed or Polamalu?

I would take Troy Polamalu over Jeff Reed all day long. Troy is a much better cover guy and tackler, but they are both about even in the kicking game.

[proudpittsburgher]

Re: Reed or Polamalu?

I would take Troy Polamalu over Jeff Reed all day long. Troy is a much better cover guy and tackler, but they are both about even in the kicking game.

Speaking of, no way Reed makes that play that suisham made on the return that almost was a TD. No way.