How would you feel about a Super Bowl ring with Rodgers?

[Eich]

Let's say the stars aligned, Rodgers pulled out his inner Tom Brady and has one of the best seasons of his career and the Steelers win number 7, mostly because of him willing it. How would you feel?

Personally, I'm sure I'd enjoy the ride but it would be missing something. There's no way I'd have the same feeling as I had when Ben - the face of our franchise - won number 5 and 6 or when Terry - also the face of the franchise - won 1-4. To me, Rodgers is the face of the Packers. And mostly an unlikable guy. And the only QB to beat Ben in a super bowl. The Steelers traditionally prided themselves on building from the draft. This is a very odd marriage.

[NorthCoast]

Not really worried about it because it won't happen. And it's not because Rodgers' is QB. It's because this team has too many other holes, questions and weak spots to compete.

["BuzzNuter"]

Throughout the SB era how many teams have won the SB with a QB they didn't draft. I can think of Jim Plunkett, Raiders and I believe Earl Morral, Dolphins. That's it.

The odds are against it happening. Rodgers kind of fits in the Earl Morral line. Oh yeah Len Dawson won for the Chiefs and we drafted him.

I just remembered Drew Brees, Saints. Peyton Manning, Broncos. What's that about every 10 years. It's been about 10 years since Manning won. Who knows.

[Joel Buchsbaum]

Let's say the stars aligned, Rodgers pulled out his inner Tom Brady and has one of the best seasons of his career and the Steelers win number 7, mostly because of him willing it. How would you feel?

Personally, I'm sure I'd enjoy the ride but it would be missing something. There's no way I'd have the same feeling as I had when Ben - the face of our franchise - won number 5 and 6 or when Terry - also the face of the franchise - won 1-4. To me, Rodgers is the face of the Packers. And mostly an unlikable guy. And the only QB to beat Ben in a super bowl. The Steelers traditionally prided themselves on building from the draft. This is a very odd marriage.

I feel great winning power ball to, but it is not going to happen.

[Eich]

Not really worried about it because it won't happen. And it's not because Rodgers' is QB. It's because this team has too many other holes, questions and weak spots to compete.

Agreed. Which makes it all the dumber to bring in a soon-to-be 42 year old QB for a year.

But the question is how you would feel IF the stars aligned and it DID happen!

[feltdizz]

Throughout the SB era how many teams have won the SB with a QB they didn't draft. I can think of Jim Plunkett, Raiders and I believe Earl Morral, Dolphins. That's it.

The odds are against it happening. Rodgers kind of fits in the Earl Morral line. Oh yeah Len Dawson won for the Chiefs and we drafted him.

I just remembered Drew Brees, Saints. Peyton Manning, Broncos. What's that about every 10 years. It's been about 10 years since Manning won. Who knows.

Tom Brady
Brett Favre
Kurt Warner
Brad Johnson
Matthew Stafford

["BuzzNuter"]

Tom Brady
Brett Favre
Kurt Warner
Brad Johnson
Matthew Stafford

Turns out it's a common occurrence. About every 5 years. Maybe a smart move on our part.

[Dog chasing Cat]

Not really worried about it because it won't happen. And it's not because Rodgers' is QB. It's because this team has too many other holes, questions and weak spots to compete.

This is a terrible thread subject. It will never happen because we have a bad owner who can’t recognize he’s out of touch with how modern teams operate and we have a cheer leader head coach who really isn’t that good of a coach.

[Eich]

This is a terrible thread subject. It will never happen because we have a bad owner who can’t recognize he’s out of touch with how modern teams operate and we have a cheer leader head coach who really isn’t that good of a coach.

It's a hypothetical. No one twisted your arm to read it or reply to it!

[hawaiiansteel]

This is a terrible thread subject. It will never happen because we have a bad owner who can’t recognize he’s out of touch with how modern teams operate and we have a cheer leader head coach who really isn’t that good of a coach.

What's up Steel Maniac?

[Northern_Blitz]

I'd feel awesome about it.

It would be a huge underdog story and one of the best playoff runs of all time.

[Iron City Inc.]

Hard to imagine us winning #7 and it not being special.

[Chucktownsteeler]

If we win a Super Bowl I don’t care who the QB is.

[hawaiiansteel]

If we win a Super Bowl I don’t care who the QB is.

My sentiments exactly.

[Flasteel]

Tom Brady
Brett Favre
Kurt Warner
Brad Johnson
Matthew Stafford

Don't forget about Dilfer!

Any Steeler fan who wouldn't be ecstatic over a Super Bowl win would reveal themself to not be a Steeler fan.