Adding Munchak: nice thought but not a fit

[whisper]

https://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/could_mike_munchak_return_to_the_steelers/s1_17181_38859225

We all loved our OL when he was here; among the best in the NFL.

But we have a OL coach, and the two do not seem to inter-mix in philosophies. Meyer has a specific technique, one I do not think Munchak shares.

I find that to be a particularly intriguing addition for Mike Tomlin given the fact that Mike Munchak knows the Steelers culture and is a former head coach. In other words, think of it as a senior offensive assistant much like the same way Teryl Austin and Brian Flores acted when that was their job on the defensive side of the football.

Maybe more as a "general hire" like Flores last year? I don't know. I feel like Munchak would not be able to just chill out watching someone else handle the OL coaching. He is a marvelous OL coach, too bad we can't figure out a way to add him. I am still not sure why he left; not sure I buy is official reason.

[Blitzer]

If the Steelers had a chance to get that guy back and didnt, then I would agree with every poster who says we lack intelligence from its leaders.

Someone like that you find a place for him.

[BURGH86STEEL]

Why did Munchak leave the Steelers?

[whisper]

Why did Munchak leave the Steelers?

I believe he said he wanted to be closer to family, daughter lived in Denver area. I think that was the word.

[hawaiiansteel]

I believe he said he wanted to be closer to family, daughter lived in Denver area. I think that was the word.

yes, that is correct:

https://247sports.com/nfl/pittsburgh-steelers/Article/Mike-Munchak-explains-reason-for-leaving-Steelers-127869439/#:~:text=“It%20was%20a%20family%20decision,else%2C%20other%20than%20family.”

[Blitzer]

I am surprised Sean Payton did not reach out to him. I guess he has his own guys.

[NorthCoast]

Munchak is old school. Denver kicked him out because he didn't fit.

[whisper]

Munchak is old school. Denver kicked him out because he didn't fit.

He was "old school" in Pgh, he put together an "old school" kick @ss OL. That was "old school" all right.

[steeler_fan_in_t.o.]

Much's specialty is the OL, but he is also a former HC. Although he wasn't successful, I am sure he understands the macro approach, working with the various coaches and assistants on a number of factors, communication etc. I would hire him as asst. HC or offensive specialist, or whatever title you want to give him. I think he would be a good set of eyes to have amongst the rest of the coaches.

[Northern_Blitz]

Why did Munchak leave the Steelers?

Reportedly to be close to family. His daughter (and maybe grandchild?). IIRC anyway

[BURGH86STEEL]

I believe he said he wanted to be closer to family, daughter lived in Denver area. I think that was the word.

I knew the answer. I am surprised you didn't come up with a "conspiracy theory" reply.

[Northern_Blitz]

Munchak is old school. Denver kicked him out because he didn't fit.

And wasn't their OL play not that good?

Munch was a good coach for the players we had at the time. Who knows if that would be true for the guys we have now.

I think the OL improved a fair amount last season. I don't think major changes are a great idea.

OTOH, LeBeau was still great when we brought him back.

[BURGH86STEEL]

And wasn't their OL play not that good?

Munch was a good coach for the players we had at the time. Who knows if that would be true for the guys we have now.

I think the OL improved a fair amount last season. I don't think major changes are a great idea.

OTOH, LeBeau was still great when we brought him back.

Lebeau was probably the only coach the Steelers rehired.

[Blitzer]

Lebeau was probably the only coach the Steelers rehired.

and at 85 he could probs still contribute to an NFL team

[Starlifter]

The Steelers acquire and release players every year in an attempt to improve the team. If a HOF talent becomes available and you have the ability to upgrade at a particular position - you have to take the shot. No reason that mindset shouldn't apply to coaches. Munch is a clear upgrade, has proven results and would improve the O-line performance. That's not to suggest last year wasn't a great job - but this is an upgrade without doubt. Take the opportunity if it comes your way.