My Qb mobility chart

[Joel Buchsbaum]

Name 1..

ok, name 2…

Now name 3..

Fleltdizz, I wasn't talking to you. Wizard replied so why do you attempt to take credit by piggybacking off his reply? Imo, Wizard is a smarter poster in comparison to you. But humor me and see it you can name an exception to the rule. Someone not named. This will be interesting.

The terms thus:

Show me the NFL qb's who have tiny hands under 9", and is one year wonders of good production in college , that scored a 17 or under in the wondererlic that tuned out to be a good pro. I am analyzing the data. I can't name one qb that was good having such low attributes. These were 210_ qb's drafted from 1990-2023. Again small hands ( less than 9" ) , a 17 or below wonderlic and a 1 year wonder of good production only. Am I describing anyone you can think of? Don't hate the data. I'm Just saying....[/QUOTE]

[Joel Buchsbaum]

Not by his avg per pass #s: he was a mere 6.2; if that doesn't improve a lot, we're headed for problems. YPP is huge. You can hang your hat on that #. And so is TD/int. He was only 7-9 there. Not good enough.

+1. Yep. You could say of he doesn't start leading the offense to more points, we are in trouble.

[Blitzer]

Fleltdizz, I wasn't talking to you. Wizard replied so why do you attempt to take credit by piggybacking off his reply? Imo, Wizard is a smarter poster in comparison to you. But humor me and see it you can name an exception to the rule. Someone not named. This will be interesting.

The terms thus:

Show me the NFL qb's who have tiny hands under 9", and is one year wonders of good production in college , that scored a 17 or under in the wondererlic that tuned out to be a good pro. I am analyzing the data. I can't name one qb that was good having such low attributes. These were 210_ qb's drafted from 1990-2023. Again small hands ( less than 9" ) , a 17 or below wonderlic and a 1 year wonder of good production only. Am I describing anyone you can think of? Don't hate the data. I'm Just saying....

[/QUOTE]

Joel,

do you think the Wonderlic matters on the field? the hand size I know everyone is concerned with but Joe Burrows hands are not much bigger and he does not have any problems

[WindyCitySteel]

the hand size I know everyone is concerned with but Joe Burrows hands are not much bigger and he does not have any problems

The hand size thing is a myth, hard to believe people still believe it. His hands are bigger than Burrow's, the NFL measurement is flawed for a number or reasons, this is one. Another is that the pinky is almost inconsequential in throwing a football, but I digress.

https://twitter.com/josephperson/sta...401242119?s=20

Pelissaro explains it at the link above. Wrapped around the ball his hand is closer to 9.5 inches, NFL measures a flat hand on the table, he can't flatten his hand. It's really that simple.

This is much ado about nothing, who else would have had more inside information than the Steelers to know this?

If someone is still promoting this as a Pickett detractor, they're either being disingenuous or are grossly ignorant of the situation. Either way, I'm tossing that person's opinions on Pickett into the rubbish bin.

[feltdizz]

Fleltdizz, I wasn't talking to you. Wizard replied so why do you attempt to take credit by piggybacking off his reply? Imo, Wizard is a smarter poster in comparison to you. But humor me and see it you can name an exception to the rule. Someone not named. This will be interesting.

The terms thus:

Show me the NFL qb's who have tiny hands under 9", and is one year wonders of good production in college , that scored a 17 or under in the wondererlic that tuned out to be a good pro. I am analyzing the data. I can't name one qb that was good having such low attributes. These were 210_ qb's drafted from 1990-2023. Again small hands ( less than 9" ) , a 17 or below wonderlic and a 1 year wonder of good production only. Am I describing anyone you can think of? Don't hate the data. I'm Just saying....

I wasn’t talking to you..

and no, I’m not answering your silly questions.

[hawaiiansteel]

Exactly, this guy just cant ever admit that he got something wrong, he just keeps moving the goal posts.

I have never met two people as unable and unwilling to ever admit they were wrong as Joel and Steel Maniac.

I'm gonna have my Tech guy check their IP addresses to see if they live within 20 miles of each other.

[WindyCitySteel]

I have never met two people as unable and unwilling to ever admit they were wrong as Joel and Steel Maniac.

You've obviously never met my wife...

[hawaiiansteel]

You've obviously never met my wife...

The Two Rules of Marriage

Rule 1 - the wife is never wrong.
Rule 2 - when the wife is wrong, see Rule 1

[Captain Lemming]

+1. Yep. You could say of he doesn't start leading the offense to more points, we are in trouble.

He will. It is what happens to rookie QBs.

[Joel Buchsbaum]

The hand size thing is a myth, hard to believe people still believe it. His hands are bigger than Burrow's, the NFL measurement is flawed for a number or reasons, this is one. Another is that the pinky is almost inconsequential in throwing a football, but I digress.

https://twitter.com/josephperson/sta...401242119?s=20

Pelissaro explains it at the link above. Wrapped around the ball his hand is closer to 9.5 inches, NFL measures a flat hand on the table, he can't flatten his hand. It's really that simple.

This is much ado about nothing, who else would have had more inside information than the Steelers to know this?

If someone is still promoting this as a Pickett detractor, they're either being disingenuous or are grossly ignorant of the situation. Either way, I'm tossing that person's opinions on Pickett into the rubbish bin.

I know you can't have a small hand. Pickett is the smallest QB hands hands in the NFL, which is large by normal human male standards. Pickett compensates a bit by wearing two pairs of gloves to help him grip the football. IMO this takes a little bit off accuracy. This is legal as long as the isn't any type of adhesion on the glove.