Are four QBs really going top ten?

[Joel Buchsbaum]

So you didn't feel the same way about Pickett because one Pitt QB made it 40 years ago? Pitt is a QB factory?

And if helmet scouting is accurate, why have there been three first round OSU QBs recently? They can't play in the NFL.

All of these guys sucked in the NFL. Every prospect in unique but at the same time there games were similar at OSU and they were mostly over drafted.

[Steel Maniac]

Herbert is 15-17 as a starter and 0-1 in the playoffs even though his defense forced 5 turnovers in on half of football.

If Kenny or Murray or anyone else you don’t like had that record and epic loss you would shred them to pieces.

Young is going 1 or 2. I doubt he drops much further than that and if he does trams will regret it. Alabama did NOT have a good OL last year compared to what they usually have. He was sacked 18 times. Maybe that is a lot for Alabama but its because Bama throws a whole lot more than they used to in the past. If you actually watched Young you would be honest and admit dude is similar to Patrick Mahomes keeping plays alive and finding open WR’s. He’s shifty. That whodini move vs Texas.. crazy.

Neither Stroud or Young are runners.. so its not important for them to run 40 times IMO.

The biggest question mark is timing. They won’t have all day to sit back and wait or run around to keep plays alive.

Levis ain’t it. Dude is all muscle, no touch and has game tapes are hard to digest.

captured for posterity.

[feltdizz]

Levis pro day. Big arm.. but tight mechanics. Struggles with touch and has mediocre footwork. Again, big arm, but misses on throws underneath and struggled with timing and touch.

basically Levis needs to stop
lifting and start stretching.

you need espn+ for this link, sorry

https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2023/i...-round-passers

[WindyCitySteel]

Levis pro day. Big arm.. but tight mechanics. Struggles with touch and has mediocre footwork. Again, big arm, but misses on throws underneath and struggled with timing and touch.

basically Levis needs to stop
lifting and start stretching.

you need espn+ for this link, sorry

https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2023/i...-round-passers

Here's film of him at his pro day, arm talent is undeniable, but then again so was Kyle Boller's.

[Oviedo]

Levis pro day. Big arm.. but tight mechanics. Struggles with touch and has mediocre footwork. Again, big arm, but misses on throws underneath and struggled with timing and touch.

basically Levis needs to stop
lifting and start stretching.

you need espn+ for this link, sorry

https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2023/i...-round-passers

Levis = Brady Quinn

[steeler_fan_in_t.o.]

Here's film of him at his pro day, arm talent is undeniable, but then again so was Kyle Boller's.

But can Levis throw 60 yards through the uprights from his knees? (I think that was Boller).

[NJ-STEELER]

Levis = Brady Quinn

jim miller ( yes the former Steelers/bears Qb) on nfl radio said he’s way to bulked up. Actually compared him to Quinn when discussing that.
needs more arm flexibility because you’ll need that to get the ball away in the nfl.

Said he was the same way because NOD was a big lifter and followed his routine when drafted by the Steelers

[NJ-STEELER]

But can Levis throw 60 yards through the uprights from his knees? (I think that was Boller).

I know you’re joking but I would guess yes.
his arm strength isn’t a question.
but it takes a lot more then that to be a successful qb in this league

[hawaiiansteel]

Wouldn't be surprised at all to see the Steelers draft a QB this year.

https://steelersdepot.com/2023/04/ra...-clayton-tune/

[Joel Buchsbaum]

NFL execs and coaches smokescreened a lot of analysts and fans last year, some who had several going in the first, including Willis #1 overall and Pickett 6th to Carolina. Fool me once...

Analysts are probably overthinking this again, seeing the next Lamar or Josh Allen in every athletic QB with a big arm. This is how gamblers go broke after winning a big bet early on.

Smart money says OL, DL, and CB dominate the picks before 1.17, unfortunately.

I just hope the go before the top 17. No, I do not think 4 qb's are going in the top ten.

Young is a runt and built like a small db. He got hurt which makes his durability a question mark, and played with Alabama where he did not shine as a passer. Yeah he made plays outside the pocket but won't be doing that as much in the NFL. IMO he is very over rated and fellow SEC champion Bennett is more impressive as a passer yet the media considers him a 3-7 round pick? Someone has to explain that to me. I don't get it. Young is a first round talent , but the are risks and flaws in his game.

Levis is a talent, but did not play as well as he should have. He is a first round talent too but despite being smart has yet to put it all together.

Stround looks and plays like a top QB. IMO he is a top five talent and should be the first player selected. The OSU QB's have not panned out.

Richardson plays like an underrated rookie, but his workout attributes are someone else. He may go in round one, but not in the top ten! Not in the top 17 IMO and if he is on the board we can used him to trade down.