Page 1 of 6 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 56

Thread: Brady is not the goat

  1. #1
    Benchwarmer

    User Info Menu

    Brady is not the goat

    Brady is now 5 and 3 in the SB. If not for a stupid play call vs the Seahawks he would be 4 and 4. One more note, if Atlanta does not melt down and give up a 21 point second half lead he is 3 and 5 in the SB.
    Brady is a great player but 3 and 5 is what he should be in the SB that's not the GOAT!

  2. #2
    Rookie

    User Info Menu

    And us being 0-3 against him in the afcc doesn't help.

  3. #3
    Hall of Famer

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by KYPITTFAN View Post
    Brady is now 5 and 3 in the SB. If not for a stupid play call vs the Seahawks he would be 4 and 4. One more note, if Atlanta does not melt down and give up a 21 point second half lead he is 3 and 5 in the SB.
    Brady is a great player but 3 and 5 is what he should be in the SB that's not the GOAT!
    You do realize defense is a part of the reason a team "wins" or loses right?
    He had 500 plus yards, 3 TDs, zero picks, and scored 34 in a "loss" right?

    Do you realize that NO TEAM HAS EVER SCORED 35 against Ben his entire playoff career......TWENTY STRAIGHT GAMES until Jax this season?
    In other words, if Ben did what Brady just did.......he would not had a single playoff loss against those teams until 2018!!!

    The scariest thing was that stinking "hail mary" was SO CLOSE to being caught. It was a perfectly executed hail Mary pass.

    You know you can "what if" those Giant loses into victories too. Could have been 7-1 in SBs.

    "What if" JH does not make a most improbable 99 yard pick 6 on a play he was supposed to be rushing the passer? That play was "at least" a 10 point swing as we had field goal range. Quite possibly a 14 point swing. On a game we BARELY won.

    Ben "could be" 1-2 in SBs. His ONE victory......being his worst SB performance.

    What if Jackie Smith makes the easiest of catches, or Swannie doesnt get an EXTREMELY questionable pi call BOTH is the same nail biter game against the Cowboys?

    Fact is if you judge Brady by rings.....he has the most.

    "What ifs" dont matter unless you do that for evrybody.

  4. #4
    Banned

    User Info Menu

    brady is the best ever.
    how many times was he on the team that had the most talent in those superbowls?

  5. #5
    Starter

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by squidkid View Post
    brady is the best ever.
    how many times was he on the team that had the most talent in those superbowls?
    Best of his generation yes. He never played QB under pre-1978 rules so you can’t say “best ever.” One could argue that Otto Graham or Johnny Unitas was the GOAT given the ERA they played in was more challenging.

  6. #6
    Benchwarmer

    User Info Menu

    And if the tuck rule had not happened Brady would have not gotten to the SB that season. Point is, yes Brady is great but a lot has went his way big games other than the Steelers have not been good to him.

    Quote Originally Posted by Captain Lemming View Post
    You do realize defense is a part of the reason a team "wins" or loses right?
    He had 500 plus yards, 3 TDs, zero picks, and scored 34 in a "loss" right?

    Do you realize that NO TEAM HAS EVER SCORED 35 against Ben his entire playoff career......TWENTY STRAIGHT GAMES until Jax this season?
    In other words, if Ben did what Brady just did.......he would not had a single playoff loss against those teams until 2018!!!

    The scariest thing was that stinking "hail mary" was SO CLOSE to being caught. It was a perfectly executed hail Mary pass.

    You know you can "what if" those Giant loses into victories too. Could have been 7-1 in SBs.

    "What if" JH does not make a most improbable 99 yard pick 6 on a play he was supposed to be rushing the passer? That play was "at least" a 10 point swing as we had field goal range. Quite possibly a 14 point swing. On a game we BARELY won.

    Ben "could be" 1-2 in SBs. His ONE victory......being his worst SB performance.

    What if Jackie Smith makes the easiest of catches, or Swannie doesnt get an EXTREMELY questionable pi call BOTH is the same nail biter game against the Cowboys?

    Fact is if you judge Brady by rings.....he has the most.

    "What ifs" dont matter unless you do that for evrybody.

  7. #7
    Legend

    User Info Menu

    Brady is great...

    at cheating
    ILB
    DL
    S
    RB
    WR
    LB


  8. #8
    Hall of Famer

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by Captain Lemming View Post
    You do realize defense is a part of the reason a team "wins" or loses right?
    He had 500 plus yards, 3 TDs, zero picks, and scored 34 in a "loss" right?

    Do you realize that NO TEAM HAS EVER SCORED 35 against Ben his entire playoff career......TWENTY STRAIGHT GAMES until Jax this season?
    In other words, if Ben did what Brady just did.......he would not had a single playoff loss against those teams until 2018!!!

    The scariest thing was that stinking "hail mary" was SO CLOSE to being caught. It was a perfectly executed hail Mary pass.

    You know you can "what if" those Giant loses into victories too. Could have been 7-1 in SBs.

    "What if" JH does not make a most improbable 99 yard pick 6 on a play he was supposed to be rushing the passer? That play was "at least" a 10 point swing as we had field goal range. Quite possibly a 14 point swing. On a game we BARELY won.

    Ben "could be" 1-2 in SBs. His ONE victory......being his worst SB performance.

    What if Jackie Smith makes the easiest of catches, or Swannie doesnt get an EXTREMELY questionable pi call BOTH is the same nail biter game against the Cowboys?

    Fact is if you judge Brady by rings.....he has the most.

    "What ifs" dont matter unless you do that for evrybody.
    Yep..your right Captain. "What if's" goes both ways. Brady has 5 rings. We just have to accept that and move on.

  9. #9
    Hall of Famer

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by feltdizz View Post
    Brady is great...

    at cheating
    And at lying about concussions thus, throwing his wife under the bus. That was such a douche bag move by him.

  10. #10
    Hall of Famer

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by The Man of Steel View Post
    Best of his generation yes. He never played QB under pre-1978 rules so you can’t say “best ever.” One could argue that Otto Graham or Johnny Unitas was the GOAT given the ERA they played in was more challenging.
    I'm sorry but I'm still taking Joe Montana over Brady.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •