Have any of yinz who are saying he's bad watched him play? If any of yinz have watched any Dolphins games, I bet you only watched the ball hoping it would go to Wally so you could see him. Or you were watching Pouncey to see if he's better than his brother. I seriously doubt anyone was watching Martin, let alone even knew who he was before this mess.
Maybe the pundits got him wrong. I don't trust most football analysts to know what's going on with a guy until he has a 2-3 year track record of success.