Results 1 to 9 of 9

Thread: Reload or Rebuild

  1. #1
    Legend
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    13,550

    Reload or Rebuild

    To think we can "Reload" would be a big mistake.

    Joe Robbins

    Since 2004, Steeler Nation has waived its Terrible Towels in three Super Bowls and more divisional playoff games and conference championships than any team other than the New England Patriots. But a price has to be paid at some point for this level of success to continue.

    What that price entails will be based on what course of action the Steelers organization chooses to take and will make this off-season unlike any other off-season that many, if not most, in Steeler Nation have ever experienced.
    To answer the question, we must understand what is being asked.
    To "Re-Load" means the Steelers front office believes it has the core players necessary to make a serious run at its seventh Lombardi trophy in 2013.
    To "Re-Build" means the Steelers front office believes the core players that have given the Steelers its fifth and sixth Lombardis have passed their prime and no longer can contribute to a Super Bowl run or justify the salaries they are making.

    "Afford" has a double meaning: the first is quite obvious in this salary cap intensive age; can the Steelers find the right mix of existing players to produce a Super Bowl contending team given the constraints of the salary cap and existing salaries?

    The second meaning of "Afford" itself has two levels of meaning.
    1) Can the Steelers "afford" to only re-load in an attempt to wring out of the remaining core players responsible for their recent past successes the last few drops of top level performance they may (or may not) have left in them? Is there enough "juice" left in Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Brett Keisel, Ike Taylor, Ryan Clark, Willie Colon and Casey Hampton to justify carrying their salaries for another year? For just as sure as a Harbaugh will win the Super Bowl this year, the window on the Steelers' Second Dynasty is closing.
    2) Can the Steelers "afford" the time it will take to re-build after its mediocre 8-8 performance this past season, and the less-than-stellar performances of its more recent draft picks such as Evander Hood, Chris Carter, Stevenson Sylvester, Jason Worilds, Jonathan Dwyer, Antonio Brown, Emmanuel Sanders and UFDA Isaac Redman? Can they wait the years it takes to re-build given the evidence of recent cracks in the invulnerability of the Steelers' franchise quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, who for the third year in a row couldn't avoid an injury that seriously hampered his ability to play at the elite level this team needs to win its seventh Lombardi trophy?

    As General Manager Kevin Colbert's recent public statements specify, the Steelers' 8-8 finish in 2012 does not lend support to any logical assumption that its current roster of players gives hope that next season will be any better. If the Steelers decide they can "afford" to just re-load, isn't that just delaying the inevitable? And if they're wrong, they've wasted another of their franchise QB's limited number of years he has left playing at a high level.

    If the Steelers decide they can only afford to re-build, what confidence do we have that the next few draft years will be better than the previous ones, which pound-for-pound have not produced players comparable to those they were drafted to replace. And can they re-build the defense using the same scheme, or do they have to consider changing that as well?

    All facets of the Steelers' performance were found wanting to one serious degree or another. The running game was inconsistent and given the questionable future of Rashard Mendenhall, there is little evidence to place much faith on the ability or durability of Dwyer or Redman to become the feature backs.

    Can the current defensive scheme afford the loss of Harrison, Hampton and/or Keisel and continue to operate as schemed? Can the secondary under Carnell Lake continue its impressive growth without a Polamalu, Lewis, Taylor or Clark? Given the structure of vaunted defensive coordinator Dick LeBeau's "bend but don't break" scheme with the imperative mission of his D-line to contain the run and his linebackers to get to the quarterback quickly to break the offense's tempo and effectiveness, failing to garner much in the way of interceptions and sacks means little or no pressure was consistently brought to bear and teams with QBs like the Dallas Cowboys' Tony Romo, San Diego Chargers' Phillip Rivers or even the Oakland Raiders' Carson Palmer and Tennessee Titans Matt Hasselbeck were able to carve up the Steelers defense and steal victories.
    So, what can the Steelers afford to do? Can they afford another mediocre season that most likely will occur if Colbert and the Rooney's declare it's time to re-build and terminate the services of many of its highly paid veterans? Can Roethlisberger, after a second off- season of deciphering Todd Haley's offense, re-emerge as one of the premier quarterbacks of the NFL behind an offensive line suddenly infused with youth but lacking experience and still be able to score enough points to compensate for a defense whose sudden youth-by-subtraction brings its continuing dominance into question?

    Or can the Steelers afford the gamble that re-loading would represent? It's a gamble that Colon can stay healthy for the majority of a season, that Kelvin Beachum has what it takes to be a true starter, or that DeCastro and Adams will perform together at a level to justify their being selected in the first and second rounds (respectively). It's a gamble that Polamalu will play more than half the season given his track record since 2009; it's a gamble that the Steelers can afford to keep Harrison and Colon and guard Ramon Foster and re-sign CB Keenan Lewis, and find a receiver to replace the production of free agent Wallace.

    If the Steelers gamble on a "re-load" by shifting the current contract monies of some/many of the players mentioned out to future years, are they not gambling the salary cap will rise sufficiently to cover the extra monies that will turn into dead money should either the gamble in 2013 not pay off and, even if it does, the eventuality that these core players' careers must come to an end?
    And if the Steelers elect to "re-build" by shedding many of the high-priced players currently under contract, are they not gambling that their current crop of young players will be affordable in a few years, but more importantly, will be performing at a post-season worthy level?
    All of this then begs another question: For Steeler Nation to remain the standard by which all other fan bases are measured, what can Steeler Nation afford to have the Steelers do, and maintain its position as the most loyal of all fan bases?


    Playing Fantasy Football does not qualify you to be the in the front office or on the coaching staff of the Pittsburgh Steelers. They are professionals and you are not!

  2. #2
    Pro Bowler
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Posts
    2,026
    Colbert has already said that when you go 12-4 you are hesitant to change much personnel wise. But when you go 8-8 and miss the play offs, it's a lot more prudent to make many more changes. They will NOT try to keep almost all of the players. We are going to see more changes than usual.

  3. #3
    Pro Bowler supersteeler's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    1,089
    We started the rebuild last season, we are in the second phase where we will see more younger players in the mix.
    Sometimes the rebuilding process can take more than a year or two, it depends on the development of new talent, and if recent draft picks step up.

    Reload is when you plug in a couple of players, but we have more things to contend with.
    We'll have a new O-line coach, special teams coach, and Haley's second year as OC, so beside players we also have change in coaches.

    For now, I just want to see us hit it in the draft, and go from there.

  4. #4
    Hall of Famer
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    3,478
    If you have good coaching in place...There is no such thing as "rebuild" or "reload". It is simply called "injecting" youth.

    So if the Steelers release vets and turn to the young players to produce & they don't..........



  5. #5
    Legend
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    13,550
    Quote Originally Posted by JUST-PLAIN-NASTY View Post
    If you have good coaching in place...There is no such thing as "rebuild" or "reload". It is simply called "injecting" youth.

    So if the Steelers release vets and turn to the young players to produce & they don't..........
    ...You find the "next guy" but you aren't hamstrung by a big veteran contract trying to milk the last drop out of a veteran who isn't performing to their contract. Every guy who we are talking about cutting because they have reached their "sell by date" was the "next guy" at some point.
    Playing Fantasy Football does not qualify you to be the in the front office or on the coaching staff of the Pittsburgh Steelers. They are professionals and you are not!

  6. #6
    Benchwarmer
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    54
    Reload - dump Harrison, Hampton, Foote, Colon and let Wallace go for starters. Pick up ILB in free agency, draft pass rushing OLB first or second round, RB second or third, WR third or fourth, TE fourth or fifth, S fifth or sixth and DL/OL sixth or seventh. Imagine as bad as our defense looked at times last year it still finished 1st in yards allowed if we actually had some pressure on the QB on a consistant basis.

  7. #7
    Legend
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Brisbane, Queensland, Australia, Australia
    Posts
    5,575
    No offense Ovi, but that's just a giant load of dribble.

    The Steelers are constantly re-loading. Step back & look at the team for a second. Ben, Miller, Colon, Troy, Keisel, Clark, Harrison, Taylor. That's the Over-30 club under contract for next season.

    Last season you had those guys, plus Foote, Starks, Hampton, Burress, Batch, Leftwich, Allen on top of that.

    The season before, Smith, Hoke etc.

    The team has been re-loading for years.

    We saw a drop-off in 2012. An 8-8 season, on the back of multiple injuries to key players- Ben, Mendenhall, Brown, Polamalu, Harrison, Woodley. If you take Flacco, Rice, Bolden, Lewis, Suggs & Reed out of the Ravens for significant time- do they make the Super Bowl?

    Last season we saw Antonio Brown, Mike Wallace, Emmanual Sanders, Marcus Gilbert, Mike Adams, Maurkice Pouncey, David DeCastro, Ziggy Hood, Lawrence Timmons, Cortez Allen, Keenan Lewis, Jonathan Dwyer & Isaac Redman step into significant roles, or maintain significant roles.

    You don't win every season. Nobody does. And the way the writer of your article finished off is more an indication of the level of supporter he is- "For Steeler Nation to remain the standard by which all other fan bases are measured, what can Steeler Nation afford to have the Steelers do, and maintain its position as the most loyal of all fan bases?"

    Steelers fans aren't fair weather fans. You ride through the good, you ride through the bad.

    This is just some schmuck's way of venting.
    Schiavone's Race Career:

    Starts- 9
    Wins- 1
    2nd- 4
    3rd- 0
    Other- 4

    Prizemoney- $28,050.00


  8. #8
    As long as we have a healthy Ben we will be in reload mode.

  9. #9
    Pro Bowler BigRob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Murfreesboro, TN
    Posts
    1,381
    Or the best solution ever: Reloadabuild!
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    That! Just happened.
    Here comes the BOOM!

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •