Gilbert did as good as you could expect. As Gilbert grows physically his game will improve. The only thing he could work on now is growing mentally as the season progresses and the pysical part will come with reps and off seasons under his belt. He will start trading off weight for muscle and his strength & agility will improve. Closing the book on Gilbert after one start is as smart as closing the book on the Steeler season after the week 1 loss to the Ravens.