At #18, I would have taken Bryan Bulaga. Didn't expect one of the "big 4" tackles to drop to us. We have no legit depth at tackle, and there is no guarantee that we will be able to sign Colon to a long-term extension if his asking price is more than we are willing to pay. As a rookie, he could start out a RG and be an upgrade to Essex, until we need him to move out to tackle.
Anyone else, feel free to add your own "What I Would Have Done" suggestions here as well. I will update mine as we go along tomorrow and Saturday. I think this is a better exercise than waiting until after it is all over and having 20-20 hindsight to be able to see where everyone fell to decide what you would have done after the fact.