
Originally Posted by
Chadman

Originally Posted by
papillon

Originally Posted by
Chadman

Originally Posted by
papillon
If the Steelers are going to make their defense younger by drafting defensive players in the 5th and 6th round they may as well not even draft them and just take players that play offense and try to outscore everyone.
The Steelers have two cornerbacks that didn't see much playing time last year, Mundy and Carter, not to mention a FS that's exploring his options. The Steelers can't afford to wait until the tail end of the draft to begin to replace these players.
Chadman, I have to say, if your mock is even remotely close I'll be very disappointed and be hoping that the offense will be able to hang 40 on every team, they'll need at least that to win games.
Pappy
Fully expect to have either Ryan Clark re-signed, or another vet FA brought in to start at FS this season- very unlikely a rookie will get to start there. What you say has merit Pap, but how many starting roles, or even contributing roles, are available on the Defense? Chris Cook would be a chance of starting, Micah Johnson has an NFL future, Robert Johnson is a quality mid-round pick & Udofia is a natural NT that won't need to see the field for 2 years anyway. Sure, the Steelers could grab a FS or CB earlier than Chadman has mocked, but not sure if the 'value' is there, when there are so many options in a strong draft for DB's. Signing Hampton takes away the need to reach for a NT, and Farrior won't be sliding over to the bench this year.
Those mid to late round selections are what well prepared teams use to fill in future role's, not current roles.
Even if the players they draft don't play this year they will have to play next year. I have to assume (at this point) that Burnett didn't have what it takes or he would have supplanted Gay at some point last year. Mundy isn't the answer or Carter would have sat. They are paper thin at ILB and even though Casey signed they need his replacement yesterday.
The offense is young, Ben, Mendy, Santonio, Wallace, Heath and the line isn't old, I believe Hartwig is the gray beard. Ben is going to get sacked 30 times a year and there isn't anything any offensive lineman can do about it, it's how he plays. The current offensive line can get a hat on a hat and drive block well enough to run the football, they just need to be asked to do it more often.
We watched this team get old in the 4th quarter all year on defense (even games that were won) they need an infusion of youth and they need it this year, IMHO.
Pappy
Agreed Pap, we watched the D get old. But....not Old at CB, or even at Safety. ILB for sure, but with Key Fox on board, and with Chadman's selection of Micah Johnson, you only need to remove Farrior to fix that. Hood will eventually move in to DE, and RaShon Harris is still on the books. So, outside of replacing Ty Carter, where are we going to get younger in a hurry? They don't need to remove 14 defensive players to 'get younger'. Just so long as they put in place measures to upgrade the D over the course of the next couple of years. If your thinking is 'get younger now', then you would advocate cutting Farrior, Aaron Smith & Casey Hampton? What about cutting Harrison too? Because really, that's where the age is.
The reality is, injuries to Smith & Polamalu hurt, Farrior declined too much for him to 'hide' after Aaron Smith went down, and Ty Carter proved to not be Troy Polamalu. The FO looks to have over valued Willie Gay, and to an extent Ryan Clark, and the rookie CB's from last year didn't turn out to be Rod Woodson. But with Smith & Polamalu back, and with the addition of a big time CB (Chris Cook), the D starts to look a whole lot better.
No, the Steelers need to get younger over the next two years. Hood saw enough time last year to be able to really help this year and there isn't any reason to believe that he can't. Casey only signed a 3 year contract, there probably won't be football in 2011, so, next year could be his last productive year, the Steelers need his replacement this year to play on third down and get experience.
Farrior shouldn't be cut, but his role should be diminished and Fox will probably get the snaps, but this year's draft should have his replacement.
The Steelers are young at corner, but Gay proved not to be the answer (maybe, he'll improve, but you need to draft just in case) and Ike was barely above average this year. Ike isn't going anywhere and rightfully so, but, they're weak on the other side.
A backup with some skills wouldn't be a bad thing for Troy either. Just too many questions without real answers on defense for me. Who was the last 4th round or later selection to help the Steelers on offense or defense? (Not counting Sepulveda, I'm talking a n every down player) Essex?
My point is that counting on late round draft picks to develop is folly, IMO. Draft em high and work them in.
Pappy
Bookmarks