Search:

Steel Torch - I seriously can't believe you don't have Tom Brady as a Top 5 QB in this league.

Statistically in 2009 Tom Brady was a better Quarterback than Kurt Warner - in Passing Yards /...

Steel Torch - I'm certainly interested in a good debate - however I'm not interested in your line of name calling - perhaps we don't agree, perhaps I'm not quite sure where you're coming from - but...

Actually YOU are the one who pointed out his -

MVP status from almost 10 years ago
His success with the Rams almost 10 years ago.
His Super Bowl Victory almost 10 years ago.
His overall playoff...

True - however if he was so good why was he eventually benched in St. Louis, and sucked in New York - is it because he went from stellar surrounding talent to mediocre surrounding talent - why else...

Feltdizz - Top 10 is very possible - top 5 = you on crack.

Consider that Warner has three very solid WR's - in fact one of them Larry Fitzgerald is a top 3 / 4 WR.

Now compare the offense...

I disagree with a number of ideas in this thread - but the top one has to be that Kurt Warner is a top 5 QB in the NFL.....ummmm - No - :nono

On his best days he needed a ton of talent to...