PDA

View Full Version : What to do with the RB situation??



AkronSteel
06-16-2012, 10:20 PM
We all know that Isaac Redman will start the season as the lead dog in the backfield and that Mendy will probably start the season on the PUP list but my question is what do you think will happen besides those two?? There is a lot of players in the race that can and might contribute. You have Jonathan Dwyer and John Clay who to me are pretty much the same guy. Each has their own qualities here and there but overall they are pretty comparable. You have Baron Batch who was a camp sensation last season and has decent size and speed, he could again impress and provide a good quality 3rd down back to replace Mewelde. Then we drafted Chris Rainey who could bring an explosiveness to the Steelers backfield that we have not witnessed in a long time, plus he provides the ability to split out and offer different options. So who do we keep?? How many do we keep?? I think four probably make it out of camp with Mendy on the PUP list so a decision will have to be made again in week 6. Precamp......I'm going like this:

Redman - obviously the lead guy to start the season and may possibly top 1000 yards depending on Mendy.
Dwyer - had some impressive moments last season in the short time he played. Gives the team a brawler.
Batch - a possible upgrade from MM as the 3rd down back with improved speed and quality blocking abilities.
Rainey - a guy that could contribute to the Steelers more in year one than most of us think with his versatility.


Clay is the odd man out to me right now but I've obviously not seen any of these guys in action since January. I would say that the last spot comes down to him and Dwyer and I feel Dwyer offers more speed than Clay so he is my choice. Let me know how you guys look at it???

hawaiiansteel
06-16-2012, 11:04 PM
a lot of course depends on whether or not Mendy starts the season on the PUP list for the first 6 games.

assuming that he does, I agree with your assessment of how things will unfold with Rainey serving as the #4 RB, #6 WR and as a KR/PR and with John Clay the odd man out.

flippy
06-17-2012, 08:06 AM
RBs is an easier position to come in and contribute immediately. Plug in anyone really. No reason we couldn't roll with Rainey if we had to.

Discipline of Steel
06-17-2012, 10:41 AM
RBs is an easier position to come in and contribute immediately. Plug in anyone really. No reason we couldn't roll with Rainey if we had to.

Except that he will most assuredly be knocked out of commision if forced to carry a bulk of the load.

Oviedo
06-17-2012, 10:53 AM
We all know that Isaac Redman will start the season as the lead dog in the backfield and that Mendy will probably start the season on the PUP list but my question is what do you think will happen besides those two?? There is a lot of players in the race that can and might contribute. You have Jonathan Dwyer and John Clay who to me are pretty much the same guy. Each has their own qualities here and there but overall they are pretty comparable. You have Baron Batch who was a camp sensation last season and has decent size and speed, he could again impress and provide a good quality 3rd down back to replace Mewelde. Then we drafted Chris Rainey who could bring an explosiveness to the Steelers backfield that we have not witnessed in a long time, plus he provides the ability to split out and offer different options. So who do we keep?? How many do we keep?? I think four probably make it out of camp with Mendy on the PUP list so a decision will have to be made again in week 6. Precamp......I'm going like this:

Redman - obviously the lead guy to start the season and may possibly top 1000 yards depending on Mendy.
Dwyer - had some impressive moments last season in the short time he played. Gives the team a brawler.
Batch - a possible upgrade from MM as the 3rd down back with improved speed and quality blocking abilities.
Rainey - a guy that could contribute to the Steelers more in year one than most of us think with his versatility.


Clay is the odd man out to me right now but I've obviously not seen any of these guys in action since January. I would say that the last spot comes down to him and Dwyer and I feel Dwyer offers more speed than Clay so he is my choice. Let me know how you guys look at it???

I think there is still a way to keep Clay if we view Rainey as the #5 WR/KR/RB. Rainey's versatility actually could allow us to keep an extra guy.

Until Mendy is healthy I have concerns at RB other than Redman.

AkronSteel
06-17-2012, 11:19 AM
I think there is still a way to keep Clay if we view Rainey as the #5 WR/KR/RB. Rainey's versatility actually could allow us to keep an extra guy.

Until Mendy is healthy I have concerns at RB other than Redman.

I have concerns as well!!! If something were to happen to Redman then we would be in a little bit of trouble just because we would have so little experience. I think Dwyer could help out but he needs to show up in shape and be ready to contribute and hopefully he can stay healthy. I never like when RB's have foot problems!!!

Sugar
06-17-2012, 02:32 PM
I feel about as good about the RB's as you can with a baller like Mendy out. There are a lot of tools with these guys. If they can pass protect and provide enough of a running threat to effectuate the passing game we're all good.

ikestops85
06-18-2012, 05:48 PM
I don't seem to be nearly as confident as a lot of you with the ability of Dwyer. I know he had the big game last year but the 2 runs that gave him the big game had holes bigger than any I had seen the team open in a long time. The other runs he had were *blah*. He seemed to go down real easy most of the time and even stopping his run when he saw defenders in the way. I just don't think Dwyer has shown he is an NFL caliber back yet. Hopefully he improves.

I haven't seen enough of Clay to have an opinion on him although I do like the effort he has shown on his few carries.

I have high hopes for Batch and Rainey but that is based on comments from OTA's and TC. Its not something I feel comfortable about.

That leaves Redman whom I do have a lot of confidence in based on past performance. I just hope he can carry the load with the 2 rookies providing help (I think Batch is still considered a rookie).

grotonsteel
06-18-2012, 08:23 PM
I feel about as good about the RB's as you can with a baller like Mendy out. There are a lot of tools with these guys. If they can pass protect and provide enough of a running threat to effectuate the passing game we're all good.

+1

Use RBs as pass catching threat and it will open up the lanes for them to run.

Djfan
06-18-2012, 11:27 PM
I would take Clay over Dwyer, just because it seems that Dwyer lacks that sizzle, and Clay may still have a chance to bring that.

Either way as far as I am concerned. When I talk with Tomlin next week I'll let him know my thoughts.

fordfixer
06-18-2012, 11:53 PM
I would take Clay over Dwyer, just because it seems that Dwyer lacks that sizzle, and Clay may still have a chance to bring that.

Either way as far as I am concerned. When I talk with Tomlin next week I'll let him know my thoughts.

You had better tell us your thought now before it dies of loneliness:D:D:D