PDA

View Full Version : I would keep Batch, at least till Ben comes back



SanAntonioSteelerFan
08-29-2010, 10:50 PM
He might be the best QB on the bench now!

Classic line by Aikman tonight: "Where's Bubby Brister?" :lol: :lol:

BURGH86STEEL
08-29-2010, 10:54 PM
He might be the best QB on the bench now!

Classic line by Aikman tonight: "Where's Bubby Brister?" :lol: :lol:

He might be the second best QB on the team. He still throws a nice ball. His only problem is he is fragile as glass. Does not take much to break Charlie.

pfelix73
08-29-2010, 10:58 PM
Agreed. He should start week 1. He has more exp. than Lefty if we're going on experience.

:tt1

feltdizz
08-29-2010, 10:58 PM
Yeah... we know Batch has moments of greatness but his durability is a concern. Tonight I watched Dixon struggle and Lefty look uninterested..

SanAntonioSteelerFan
08-29-2010, 11:00 PM
He might be the best QB on the bench now!

Classic line by Aikman tonight: "Where's Bubby Brister?" :lol: :lol:

He might be the second best QB on the team. He still throws a nice ball. His only problem is he is fragile as glass. Does not take much to break Charlie.

He's a real good teammate too, he threw that pic just to keep Lefty and Dix from feeling bad.

pfelix73
08-29-2010, 11:02 PM
Not sure, only the coaches will know, but that may have been a bad route by the WR. In which case, not Batch's fault if it was.

:tt1

stlrz d
08-29-2010, 11:08 PM
Not sure, only the coaches will know, but that may have been a bad route by the WR. In which case, not Batch's fault if it was.

:tt1

WR definitely missed the hot read.

I always chuckle at the fragile comments. Weird injuries happen all the time. Batch got pounded pretty good a few times tonight and bounced right up.

ANPSTEEL
08-29-2010, 11:14 PM
If batch gets cut

Arizona will sign him faster than you can say our OLine sucks

RuthlessBurgher
08-29-2010, 11:21 PM
Arizona has Matt Leinart, Derek Anderson, and rookie John Skelton (they got they got with the Santonio pick that we gave them for BMac and their 6th round pick that they used on Antonio Brown). Who would they get rid of for a 35 year old Batch who has never thrown to any of these Cardinal receivers before.

We can cut Batch, and he should still be available in the case of catastrophic injury to Byron or Dennis during the first 4 games.

ANPSTEEL
08-29-2010, 11:37 PM
Arizona has Matt Leinart, Derek Anderson, and rookie John Skelton (they got they got with the Santonio pick that we gave them for BMac and their 6th round pick that they used on Antonio Brown). Who would they get rid of for a 35 year old Batch who has never thrown to any of these Cardinal receivers before.

We can cut Batch, and he should still be available in the case of catastrophic injury to Byron or Dennis during the first 4 games.


I was being serious.

Leinart has sucked so much this pre-season, he's been benched for Anderson.

If you are benched for Derek Anderson- who couldn't beat out Brady Quinn - you suck.

There are some rumblings coming from AZ that Leinart may be in jeopardy of being cut.

kiwi_sarah
08-30-2010, 07:47 AM
He might be the best QB on the bench now!

Classic line by Aikman tonight: "Where's Bubby Brister?" :lol: :lol:

He might be the second best QB on the team. He still throws a nice ball. His only problem is he is fragile as glass. Does not take much to break Charlie.

http://img576.imageshack.us/img576/2378/unbreakable3i.jpg (http://img576.imageshack.us/i/unbreakable3i.jpg/)

Batch = Mr Glass? :D

JPbucco
08-30-2010, 07:56 AM
Dumbest.Thread.Ever.

Djfan
08-30-2010, 09:13 AM
Dumbest.Thread.Ever.

Unfortunately, that is not true.

Still, the fragile Batch comments are unfounded. He offers a lot, and should be kept IMO. How? I don't know, but he seems to be overlooked for no real reason. Lefty is a bandaid, much the same as Batch.

RuthlessBurgher
08-30-2010, 10:14 AM
Dumbest.Thread.Ever.

Unfortunately, that is not true.

Still, the fragile Batch comments are unfounded. He offers a lot, and should be kept IMO. How? I don't know, but he seems to be overlooked for no real reason. Lefty is a bandaid, much the same as Batch.

Yeah, but the Byron band-aid is 5 years younger than the Batch band-aid. Band-aids tend to lose some of their stickiness over the course of 5 years.

proudpittsburgher
08-30-2010, 10:58 AM
The Steelers find themelves in an interesting position. CB outplayed both backup QBs last night. I was firmly in support of Leftwich playing the first four games on experience only, started to waiver a little bit until I saw the game last night, then I got back in the Lefty camp, although I didn't feel very good about it. Then I saw Batch play and now I don't know what to think. Charlie played against the third team, true enough, but he was pressured on just about every throw, and he read it every time and got a good ball out to the reciever. That's all you can ask out of your Qb at this point. Read the blitz, and get the ball out correctly. I still think the pick 6 was an error on the part of the receiver and that shouldn't happen playing with first teamers. Obviously, we can't keep all three of them, and we aren't getting rid of Dennis Dixon (rightfully so) but at this point, Batch in limited time has played all around better than Lefty. Lefty has more years ahead of him, I think, so that is in his favor as a backup, but what in the hell do the steelers do here?

RuthlessBurgher
08-30-2010, 12:26 PM
People overreact to what they have last seen. The ultimate "what have you done for me lately" point of view. For some reason, only last night matters, and the previous two preseason games, all of training camp, and all of the OTA's are thrown right out the window. Based on everything that I have seen and heard so far (not just last night like the reactionaries), this is what I expect to happen:

Leftwich will start the first 4 games.

Dixon will be used in special packages in the first 4 games.

Batch will be cut so that we can keep a 9th LB or 6th WR or 7th DL or whatever.

If Byron or Dennis experience a significant injury while Ben is still out, then you call Charlie back in, since another team is not going to pluck a 35 year old 4th team QB who does not know their offensive system (yes, even the Cardinals).

If both Byron and Dennis were injured in the same game, we could finish with some combination of Antwaan Randle El, Arnaz Battle, and Hines Ward taking snaps, since they all played QB in college.

SanAntonioSteelerFan
08-30-2010, 12:37 PM
People overreact to what they have last seen. The ultimate "what have you done for me lately" point of view. For some reason, only last night matters, and the previous two preseason games, all of training camp, and all of the OTA's are thrown right out the window. Based on everything that I have seen and heard so far (not just last night like the reactionaries), this is what I expect to happen:

Leftwich will start the first 4 games.

Dixon will be used in special packages in the first 4 games.

Batch will be cut so that we can keep a 9th LB or 6th WR or 7th DL or whatever.

If Byron or Dennis experience a significant injury while Ben is still out, then you call Charlie back in, since another team is not going to pluck a 35 year old 4th team QB who does not know their offensive system (yes, even the Cardinals).

If both Byron and Dennis were injured in the same game, we could finish with some combination of Antwaan Randle El, Arnaz Battle, and Hines Ward taking snaps, since they all played QB in college.

That would be cool. Imagine if someone were to draw up some kind of trick play where ARE might pass to Hines, there might be potential for a big play there. Nah, it could never happen! :wink:

fordfixer
08-30-2010, 01:00 PM
People overreact to what they have last seen. The ultimate "what have you done for me lately" point of view. For some reason, only last night matters, and the previous two preseason games, all of training camp, and all of the OTA's are thrown right out the window. Based on everything that I have seen and heard so far (not just last night like the reactionaries), this is what I expect to happen:

Leftwich will start the first 4 games.

Dixon will be used in special packages in the first 4 games.

Batch will be cut so that we can keep a 9th LB or 6th WR or 7th DL or whatever.

If Byron or Dennis experience a significant injury while Ben is still out, then you call Charlie back in, since another team is not going to pluck a 35 year old 4th team QB who does not know their offensive system (yes, even the Cardinals).

If both Byron and Dennis were injured in the same game, we could finish with some combination of Antwaan Randle El, Arnaz Battle, and Hines Ward taking snaps, since they all played QB in college.

That would be cool. Imagine if someone were to draw up some kind of trick play where ARE might pass to Hines, there might be potential for a big play there. Nah, it could never happen! :wink:


Not with Bruce as the O.C. :HeadBanger

Discipline of Steel
08-30-2010, 06:02 PM
Look at the body of work over the entire pre-season, factor in trends, and then decide.

fezziwig
08-30-2010, 08:05 PM
They said today on the radio if Batch is on the team come the first game of the season Batch, is guaranteed $850,000.00 I bet that has something to do with it.

Between getting rid of Batch and Hartwig, the Steelers save I believe close to 3 mil. I think Hartwig would get 1.8 mil.