PDA

View Full Version : Steelers must decide if franchise or transition tags



fordfixer
01-01-2010, 09:40 AM
Steelers must decide if franchise or transition tags work for possible free agents

By Mark Kaboly, TRIBUNE-REVIEW
Friday, January 1, 2010
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsbu ... 60327.html (http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/sports/steelers/s_660327.html)

Ryan Clark would love it, but don't even bring the subject to Casey Hampton.

To franchise or not to franchise, that's the question surrounding a handful of Steelers very shortly.

"No, I don't want a franchise tag," Hampton said.

If Sunday's game in Miami is the final one of the year for the defending World Champion Steelers, the organization will have about a month to decide on what they want to do with some of their key unrestricted free agents like Clark, Hampton, Jeff Reed and Willie Parker.

Do they sign them to a long-term deal?

Do they cut ties with them?

Or do they place the franchise and transition tag on any of them?

An exclusive franchise tag allows a team to strategically retain would-be free agents by offering them a one-year deal that pays them the average of the top five players at their position.

The non-exclusive franchise tag, which almost always is used instead, allows the player to shop his services to other teams, but the organization would have a chance to match any offer.

A transition tag is the average of the top 10 salaries of previous year at the player's position also with a chance to match any offer.

The Steelers used the transition tag on tackle Max Starks two years ago and the non-exclusive franchise tag this year at a price tag of $8.45 million before signing him to a 4-year, $26.3 million long term deal shortly after.

That could be the avenue the Steelers take with Hampton.

Hampton's salary is only $3.075 million this year, down slightly from last year. If the Steelers choose to franchise Hampton, who was selected to his fifth Pro Bowl earlier in the week, it would double his salary to a little more than $6 million for the 2010 season.

"That is something I do not want," Hampton said.

That's because at 32, Hampton doesn't want to risk injury that could prevent him for cashing in on possibly his last long-term, high paying contract especially after the season he is having.

"I think when I am healthy that I am a dominant player," Hampton said.

With the uncertainty of the CBA and a real possibility of an uncapped year in 2010 and 2011, teams will have more franchise opportunities than years past.

Currently, a team can put either a franchise tag or a transition tag on any one player. If the NFL gets to an uncapped year in 2010 and 2011 like expected, teams will have use of one franchise tag and two transition tags.

That means the Steelers could use the tag in multiple instances this offseason.

Clark could be one of them, but it would be highly unlikely, even if there is nobody in place behind him to take his starting free safety spot.

"A lot of uncertainty is with the new CBA," Clark said. "I would love to be franchised. You don't get any longevity or security and that's the thing about it."

Clark is in the final year of a 4-year deal that pays him $1.75 million a season. A franchise tag would cost the Steelers more than $6 million while the transition tag would be a little more than $5 million.

To put that into perspective, Troy Polamalu makes just less than $7 million per season.

"I am not good enough (to get franchised)," Clark said. "You all keep saying this stuff. The really good players are the ones you franchise. Guys like me don't get franchised. They are not going to franchise me. For Casey it probably wouldn't be so bad."

Kicker Jeff Reed is also a franchise/transition possibility. He is in the final year of his deal that pays him about $1.5 million a year and a franchise or transition would cost the Steelers anywhere between $750,000 to $1 million more than what they are paying him now.

Willie Parker wouldn't make much sense at all to slap a tag on him.

His making close to $4 million this year and the franchise number will be close to $7 million.

Parker lost his starting job to first round pick Rashard Mendenhall.

Oviedo
01-01-2010, 09:44 AM
Reed is the only player I would consider tagging out of that group.

Letting the others go would clear about $8-10M in cap space that could be used for securing (Woodley, Holmes) or acquiring longer term solutions.

Mister Pittsburgh
01-01-2010, 10:27 AM
Reed is the only player I would consider tagging out of that group.

Letting the others go would clear about $8-10M in cap space that could be used for securing (Woodley, Holmes) or acquiring longer term solutions.

You mention Woodley & Holmes, which I agree are must keeps....but what do you do with Timmons?

steelblood
01-01-2010, 10:36 AM
Timmons has two years left on his rookie deal after this season. There is no reason to extend him.

Also, if there is no new CBA, Woodley would not become a UFA for 3 more seasons. Holmes would have two years left.

papillon
01-01-2010, 12:00 PM
Since, specialists are all the rage these days, rather than have a KO return specialist, I would tag Reed and pay the extra 750K to 1 million for his FG services, release Logan and sign a strong legged kicker for KOs to the league minimum.

Casey knows the situation and he has to realize he isn't getting another 5 year deal for over 6 million per year. The Steelers may be able to work out a deal that can work for both sides. If I were the Steelers I would determine what his services are worth for the next two years and guarantee him that over 4 years, then if you part ways it isn't too detrimental to the cap situation.

Ryan Clark is probably gone after this year or they'll try and sign him at his current salary for a few more years to team with Troy.

Pappy

Shawn
01-01-2010, 01:17 PM
I think we are all going to be surprised. At 32...the Steelers have the power not Hampton. He does not want a transition tag for obvious reasons. The Steelers will threaten it...and he will sign a reasonable contract.

phillyesq
01-01-2010, 05:25 PM
The Steelers should absolutely tag Hampton, and they probably will. Over the past few seasons, they have tried to give themselves options going into the draft so they are not forced to take any position out of need. Tagging Hampton gives them an option. If he isn't tagged, the Steelers absolutely need to draft a NT or sign a FA.

I think a tag for Reed could make a lot of sense. His kickoffs undoubtedly leave a lot to be desired, but he is reliable, and he knows how to kick at Heinz Field. Looking at the kicking problems through the league, retaining Reed is a smart move.

I wonder whether somebody will throw big money at Parker. If he doesn't get an opportunity elsewhere, it could make sense to bring him in for near the vet minimum to backup Mendy.

Clark really struggled this year, but he plays well with Troy. If he can be resigned to a reasonable deal, then I'm fine with him coming back for another year. The struggles of the secondary will probably hurt his market value. With his recent comments in the media, I can see him moving on.

Oviedo
01-02-2010, 10:07 AM
The Steelers should absolutely tag Hampton, and they probably will. Over the past few seasons, they have tried to give themselves options going into the draft so they are not forced to take any position out of need. Tagging Hampton gives them an option. If he isn't tagged, the Steelers absolutely need to draft a NT or sign a FA.

I think a tag for Reed could make a lot of sense. His kickoffs undoubtedly leave a lot to be desired, but he is reliable, and he knows how to kick at Heinz Field. Looking at the kicking problems through the league, retaining Reed is a smart move.

I wonder whether somebody will throw big money at Parker. If he doesn't get an opportunity elsewhere, it could make sense to bring him in for near the vet minimum to backup Mendy.

The defense we plan to run in the future will determine whether you are going to pay $6M to Hampton. IMO that is way too much.

Clark really struggled this year, but he plays well with Troy. If he can be resigned to a reasonable deal, then I'm fine with him coming back for another year. The struggles of the secondary will probably hurt his market value. With his recent comments in the media, I can see him moving on.

NorthCoast
01-02-2010, 10:28 AM
The Steelers should absolutely tag Hampton, and they probably will. Over the past few seasons, they have tried to give themselves options going into the draft so they are not forced to take any position out of need. Tagging Hampton gives them an option. If he isn't tagged, the Steelers absolutely need to draft a NT or sign a FA.

I think a tag for Reed could make a lot of sense. His kickoffs undoubtedly leave a lot to be desired, but he is reliable, and he knows how to kick at Heinz Field. Looking at the kicking problems through the league, retaining Reed is a smart move.

I wonder whether somebody will throw big money at Parker. If he doesn't get an opportunity elsewhere, it could make sense to bring him in for near the vet minimum to backup Mendy.

Clark really struggled this year, but he plays well with Troy. If he can be resigned to a reasonable deal, then I'm fine with him coming back for another year. The struggles of the secondary will probably hurt his market value. With his recent comments in the media, I can see him moving on.

I agree philly. This is the mode they followed with Starks and if I recall correctly there was bloody murder being screamed on MBs about the whole contract thing with him. In the end, the front office and coaching staff knew best. Casey has played very well this season. The question comes down to how long he can really keep up this pace. Joel Steed played 7 yrs at NT and was slightly lighter than Casey. Casey is in his 8th season in a position that takes an absolute pounding on every defensive snap. I honestly expect a 1 yr or short term deal for him and drafting his replacement if there is one available.
In a 3-4 defense, if you do not control the nose, you will not be a good defender against the rush.