PDA

View Full Version : Rank the QBs...AKA help Ben!



stlrz d
03-20-2009, 09:39 AM
http://sports.espn.go.com/chat/sportsna ... &listId=23 (http://sports.espn.go.com/chat/sportsnation/rank?versionId=3&listId=23)

RuthlessBurgher
03-20-2009, 09:52 AM
Ben is in 4th place right now (62,471 votes cast)

Player (first place votes) total points

1 Tom Brady (27,617) 1,946,408
2 Peyton Manning (25,178) 1,918,769
3 Drew Brees (3,092) 1,766,631
4 Ben Roethlisberger (1,680) 1,606,324
5 Kurt Warner (548) 1,417,510
6 Eli Manning (286) 1,415,300
7 Philip Rivers (605) 1,409,634
8 Donovan McNabb (251) 1,398,511
9 Jay Cutler (808) 1,344,501
10 Carson Palmer (110) 1,266,999
11 Tony Romo (287) 1,251,369
12 Matt Ryan (180) 1,104,898
13 Matt Cassel (110) 1,033,018
14 Matt Hasselbeck (87) 949,223
15 Aaron Rodgers (225) 897,147
16 Joe Flacco (112) 848,428
17 Kerry Collins (37) 845,893
18 Chad Pennington (81) 814,177
19 Jake Delhomme (40) 807,282
20 Marc Bulger (33) 748,421
21 Jeff Garcia (17) 666,792
22 Jason Campbell (158) 645,342
23 David Garrard (25) 627,274
24 Trent Edwards (146) 604,638
25 Derek Anderson (100) 558,301
26 Matt Schaub (24) 532,850
27 Brady Quinn (114) 492,141
28 Kyle Orton (138) 391,325
29 Shaun Hill (85) 304,846
30 JaMarcus Russell (143) 297,587
31 Tarvaris Jackson (95) 292,633
32 Matthew Stafford (32) 265,272
33 Mark Sanchez (27) 225,997

stlrz d
03-20-2009, 10:01 AM
I put Ben first and then started at the bottom with Brady, Manning and so on up. :tt2

RuthlessBurgher
03-20-2009, 10:04 AM
I put Ben first and then started at the bottom with Brady, Manning and so on up. :tt2

So who came in second place for you? Sanchez? Tarvaris? JaMarcus? Shaun Hill?

stlrz d
03-20-2009, 11:01 AM
I put Ben first and then started at the bottom with Brady, Manning and so on up. :tt2

So who came in second place for you? Sanchez? Tarvaris? JaMarcus? Shaun Hill?

:lol: The others you named were right up there too. :D

Northern_Blitz
03-20-2009, 02:23 PM
I listed them in the order I believe they go:

Brady
Ben
P.Manning

I put a couple of garbage guys at 4 & 5, because you had to put 5. I think the next group is pretty close (Rivers, Breese, McNabb, Carson etc.). All have put up some good numbers, but haven't really won anything. I was thinking about putting Warner next, but I looked at it more like who would you want now, as opposed to who had a better career. In that light I couldn't see giving up Ben for anyone, except maybe Brady (if I knew he was healthy). I also thought about putting Eli next, but I don't watch enough Giants games and I feel like he wasn't that big a part of their SB win (although I'm sure people say the same about Ben).

*Note, this order gives Brady the benifit of the doubt that the cheating didn't really make too much difference.

frankthetank1
03-21-2009, 10:33 AM
I listed them in the order I believe they go:

Brady
Ben
P.Manning

I put a couple of garbage guys at 4 & 5, because you had to put 5. I think the next group is pretty close (Rivers, Breese, McNabb, Carson etc.). All have put up some good numbers, but haven't really won anything. I was thinking about putting Warner next, but I looked at it more like who would you want now, as opposed to who had a better career. In that light I couldn't see giving up Ben for anyone, except maybe Brady (if I knew he was healthy). I also thought about putting Eli next, but I don't watch enough Giants games and I feel like he wasn't that big a part of their SB win (although I'm sure people say the same about Ben).

*Note, this order gives Brady the benifit of the doubt that the cheating didn't really make too much difference.

i would actually put brees above manning and brady if this list is talent right now, not going on the past. if brees was ever on a playoff caliber team then i think he would have won something. i agree with you eli was not a huge part of the sb win. his regular season that year was pretty bad. he got hot in the post season but his wr's bailed him out in the sb. i think eli is the most overrated qb i have ever seen